5 things I missed: ABC Family Movies
If they'd released these in theaters they;d be cult classics.
If you suffer from crippling nostalgia for the 2000s, you really should be watching ABC Family movies. The network produced the kind of feel-good fun comedies that Hollywood was starting to abandon in the 2000s. And they did a pretty job. If these made it to theaters, they'd be cult classics. We'd be drowing in memes from these movies. And some of these are actually quite good! If you like these, I also recommend the Ryan Reynolds/David Paymer vehicle School of Life (prime gas leak cinema) and the Shiri Appleby-Nick Zano rom-com Everything You Want (a good movie!).
She Gets What She Wants aka Slap Her, She's French (premiered January 9, 2005)
This was clearly developed in the wake of Bring It On, and it fits neatly into the tradition of homoerotic teen girl comedies. It was likely intended for theatrical release, and it did get released in Europe. But in the US it got shelved and ended up on ABC Family.
A Canadian doing a bad Texas accent plays cheerleader pageant queen Starla, who dreams of hosting Good Morning America like Diane Sawyer. Her family takes on French foreign exchange student Genevieve le Plouff (Piper Perabo). Before long, Genevieve is going full Single White Female on the Canadian Texan: she steals her boyfriend (Matt Czuchry), her spot on the cheerleading squad, even her journalistic ambitions. It's an insane premise, it's very acidic and mean, the tone is always at an 11. It could be a cult classic, and it probably would be if it was more available (I had to get a DVD through Inter-Librar Loan).
Pop Rocks! (premiered September 10, 2004)
Now this movie really should have been in theaters. It's almost too good. The premise is killer: the lead singer of a bad '80s rock band has reinvented himself as a suburban dad, and his past is revealed when his band wants to do a reunion concert. Gary Cole is a perfect lead. The songs are really good, totally credible as mid-tier '80s rock, and the movie opens with a great parody of a Behind the Music-style documentary. And I liked the message too. Gary Cole is eager to reject his rocker past, and he's not totally wrong; songs like "jailbait" hit different when you're an adult and a dad. But over the course of the movie he comes to understand that his suburban existence has its own problems: the sterile bank job, the crushing of his kids' dreams, the rigid gender roles that are destroying his marriage. And by the end of the movie, he learns to embrace the good parts of rock and reject all that. There's an epic scene where he quits the bank and tells off his boss, very satisfying! Down with capitalism! Dare I say it, but this ABC Family movie is funny, genuinely heartwarming, and even kinda woke? Give this thing a real budget and a theatrical release and it's a cult classic today.
Love Rules! (premiered June 5, 2004)
A fascinating document of Gen-X ambivalence towards marriage! Maggie Lawson and Joey Lawrence are ready to tie the knot, but as soon as they announce their plans, everything goes sour. Their plans for a simple wedding are thwarted at every turn, and everyone is telling them that they will be miserable. Worse, everyone and everything starts encouraging them to be the worst version of themselves, and it starts to work. Everyone becomes jealous and stops communicating. It's a silly ABC Family movie, but it's also an interrogation of toxic heteronormativity! No, really!
Of course, they do get married in the end. If you're a sappy person like me, you can see this as two people who love each other marching into a new chapter (and their decisions throughout the movie, like him ditching his sexist friends and her improving her relationship with her mom, make me more willing to buy this happy ending). But if you want to see this as a movie about how marriage is a broken institution, the ending is a true Rorschach test. It can be a happily ever after, but it can also be the ending of The Graduate.
Crimes of Fashion (premiered July 5, 2004)
Kaley Cuoco is a student at Fashion University (I'm not being cute, that's the name) when she discovers that she's the granddaughter of a mobster. With the help of lovable old fixer Dominic Chianese, she uses her fashion skills to take the business legit, falls in love with the undercover FBI agent trying to take her down, and discovers that her fashion school rival Megan Fox stole all her designs from the housekeeper. It's the kind of lunacy that only a TV movie can provide, and I had fun.
The Hollow (premiered October 24, 2004)
If you like '90s and 2000s tween horror, this should scratch that itch. Honestly, my favorite part was the opening credits. It's quite the collection of names, and we get two "with" credits, one "and" credit, and even an "also starring" credit.