What was on TV? Tues, May 31, 2005
Deadliest Catch is a capitalism horror story. Plus The Shield and the Chappelle season that wasn't
On May 31, 2005, Late Night writers across America received some devastating news: Watergate whistleblower "Deep Throat" had finally revealed his identity. And they were all on vacation. Let's see what was on TV.

9:00 Deadliest Catch on Discovery
1x08 "Good Fishing"
Deadliest Catch was always one of the classier reality shows, a show for people who don't watch reality TV. I can see why. It's thrilling to get a look at such a beautiful and remote part of the globe. The stakes are very high, these men are fighting for their livelihoods and risking their lives. Exciting stuff.
But I wonder if people respect Deadliest Catch because it's about men. My beloved Laguna Beach is full of beautiful locations, it has better editing and cinematography, and the stakes are very high even if no one is in danger of losing their life of financial security.
But I think that's the real secret of Deadliest Catch. Too much television, in the reality genre and outside of it, is about rich people. On Deadliest Catch, these men are fighting every day to make ends' meet. Nature could ruin their plans at any moment, destory everything they've worked so hard for. That's capitalism! That's the real theme of this show, the unspoken economic structure that governs our lives. It's thrilling to see it dramatized so vividly.

10:00 The Shield on FX
4x11 "A Thousand Deaths"
Maybe Glenn Close's best episode to date? It's certainly the most I've liked Captain Rawlins. She pushes the strike team to find a pair of cop-killers, and she gets results. But she's watching them closely. They stay on her leash. Meanwhile, the higher ups are questioning her civil asset forfeiture policy. For good reason, it is deeply flawed. But she sticks to her guns and holds the line. She's not burdened by the secrets and fragile masculinity that hobble the boys who surround her. She knows who she is and what she believes in.
Me thinking all this no doubt means things will go south for her in a big way in the weeks to come.
What Else Was On
- It was customary for shows to run a minute or two past the hour in this era. This meant that the end of the episode would be cut off if you DVRed it. This would encourage viewers to watch the episode live. But the WB ran into the perils of this strategy when the season finale of Gilmore Girls ran about 30 seconds over and anyone who watched American Idol and recorded Gilmore Girls missed Luke proposing to Lorelai. People were pissed, and the WB had to schedule an emergency encore 2 weeks later.
- Robin Schiff also developed the Jenny McCarthy UPN sitcom The Bad Girl's Guide. She doesn't receive "creator" credit so I assume she was kicked off the project. Anyway, it lasted six episodes.
- ABC began burning off the rest of its blind cop show Blind Justice.
TV news, circa 2005
The third season of Chappelle's Show was supposed to premiere tonight. Comedy Central was airing promos as late as May 4. But then the news broke: production had halted, and Chappelle had run away to South Africa and checked himself into a mental health facility. There would be no third season.
Chappelle's Show was a huge deal. It was a ginormous hit for Comedy Central. It was a critically acclaimed comedy at a time when comedy seemed downright endangered. The first season DVD broke sales records, so did the second season. Even after the third season fell apart, even after Chappelle ran away, Comedy Central was still airing reruns and his stand-up specials, they'd signed a $50 million deal with the man, after all. He was huge, and poised to become huger. Then he walked away.
I wish I'd started this project earlier, so I could track the show's golden age. I know Chappelle as an out-of-touch crank. In the course of this project, I've only ever seen him make a creepy and mean Janet Jackson joke at the VMAs. But this man was once a visionary! Some day I'll have to find out why.
If you want to learn more about Chappelle's flight from the spotlight, I recommend this Entertainment Weekly story.