5 things I missed: Award Shows
The tears, the jeers, the upsets, the speeches, and the performances of 2004 and 2005
This blog is a series of time capsules. Every piece of television I review, from the fanciest HBO drama to the trashiest reality show, reveals something about life in the mid-2000s.
But there is no better time capsule than an award show. They reveal what specific subcultures, from the Hollywood elite to the MTV crowd, valued and wanted to promote. They reveal what parts of the past people wanted to celebrate and what they thought the future of entertainment might look like. And they are of course a goldmine for bizarre moments, iconic musical performances, big speeches, and more. Let's dive into five award shows from 2004 and 2005.
2004 MTV Video Music Awards
Sunday, August 29, 2004
The VMAs are MTV's signature event. They are famous for crazy stunt and transgressive moments. But about 6 months before the 2004 VMAs, there was a very VMAs coded moment at the Super Bowl Halftime show. MTV produced that show, and the wardrobe malfunction hear aroundthe world was a bridge to far for America, and for the higher-ups at Viacom.
So the 2004 VMAs were mostly stunt-free. This one was about the music. So it's a good thing that the music was good. Outkast, Beyonce, Lil John, Jay-Z, Usher, Britney Spears, Kanye West was fresh on the scene. Has pop music ever been this good again? I did so much chair dancing while watching this show. The music was irresistible!
This year's VMAs were in Miami, and MTV was serious about it. JLo introduced the show, Will Smith introduced Shaq, and Shakira was there soon after. The pandering worked. The crowd was hyped. Later in the show Diddy announced that he was officially a resident of Miami Beach, and these are all his people right here, which feels like a threat in hindsight. But the pandering worked! The crowd was hyped. Part of what made the VMAs so special is that the crowd was filled with fans ready to party, not just artists and industry types. It makes the whole show feel so alive, even in a toned-down year like this one.
The show opens with Usher, who performs "Confessions" shirtless in the rain and smashes a glass wall with his mic stand as Lil John and Ludacris storm the stage for "Yeah!" The crowd went crazy. How could they not?
Other memorable moments:
- Newlyweds was a huge hit for MTV at this time so star Jessica Simpson gets a full two-song set and it's kind of a struggle. She doesn't have a second hit so she performs a Robbie Williams cover.
- MTV was all about getting out the vote, see my election day episodes roundup for more on that. They made John Kerry's daughters come out and they got booed but handled themselves well. (The Bush daughters appeared via satellite. Chicken!). Diddy also promoted his "Vote or Die" campaign by bringing out a bunch of hot girls. Outkast closed the show with a whole get out the vote themed performance. MTV was very serious about this.
- Britney Spears did not show up which is probably why she didn't win anything but come on! Nothing for the "Toxic" video?
- The only one to mention the Super Bowl incident was Dave Chappelle who said that "Justin should never have apologized. Pull it out! Like you mean it!" and then he did a yanking motion. Gross. Mean. Violent. Boo.
- MTV reached peak 2004 when they invented an award for "video game soundtrack" so they could give it to Tony Hawk. Bizarre from D12 announced it: "and the winner for the uh...whatever." So true, Bizarre, so true.
2004 MTV Movie Awards
Friday, June 10, 2004
MTV was avoiding scandal on the VMAs, but they were dancing awfully close to the sun at their Movie Awards. Because they hired Lindsey Lohan to host.
This was peak Lindsey Lohan. Freaky Friday was already out and she won an award for it. Mean Girls was about a month into its run. And now Lindsey Lohan, at just 17, is hosting the MTV Movie Awards.
She's honestly pretty good? We open with a skit starring Rachel Dratch and Andy Richter as her parents, who really aren't sure about this. But she can't be stopped! She strips off her jacket and does and entire hip-hop dance with the cast of You Got Served. She's committed, but she still looks like a white girl. But this is perfect for the very 2004 teen girl fantasy this is catering to. The racial and gender dynamics are wild, but you know what? She served!
She is very good in the sketches, including one with Adam Brody and Jamie Lee Curtis that parodies the 4-way Mean Girls call. She makes the canned introductions of the presenters sound cool and natural. She ends by saying she has to go drink some non-alcoholic punch at the afterparty. Which is kind of depressing since you know she didn't stick to the punch. But then in the credits montage Shia LaBeouf says that MTV could make a lot of money by filming her in the bathroom. And I understand why she hated being sober.
Some more highlights from the night:
- Tom Cruise and Jamie Foxx present, and Foxx wants a special message for his girlfriend! Tom puts on the sunglasses and goes into full movie star mode while Foxx films him with a camcorder; the crowd goes wild. One year later, he will hop on Oprah's couch.
- Eli Roth directed incredibly disturbing CGI horror interstitials. Would have scarred me forever if I saw this in middle school.
- Will Ferrell was promoting Anchorman and did a sketch in character as Ron Burgundy, in which he interviewed Passion of the Christ star Jim Caviezel, except he thinks that Caviezel is really Jesus. A hilarious parody of inane celebrity interviews that's aged beautifully. The second sketch with Rebecca Romijn is kind of gross though.
- Snoop Dogg and Paris Hilton present best kiss. Because this is Paris Hilton, the obligatory bit where she kisses him on the cheek feel very rehearsed which is honestly for the best. Winner Carmen Elektra kisses them both and that feels rehearsed too. Girl kissing at awards shows was such a cliche by then, this barely moved the needle.
- Jimmy Fallon does the worm to "Toxic" and tells us all that he hurt his ball. Queen Latifah has to be involved.
- There's a hilarious sketch regulated to the aftershow about "Craig Jeffrey, the movie reviewer who loves every movie" and always ends up on the poster. The Day After Tomorrow, Jersey Girl, From Justin to Kelly, Garfield? He loves them! The Alamo? "You will never forget!" It says so right there on the poster. Peter Travers found dead.
- This was The Lonely Island's first Hollywood gig, though most of the material they wrote didn't make it to air. But you can see their names in the credits.
2004 BET Awards
Tuesday, June 29, 2004
Forget MTV. In 2004, BET was the place to be. Lindsey did okay, but Mo'nique leaves her in the dust.
This is how you host an awards show. Mo'nique appears with a bunch of back-up dancers and we hear the iconic opening notes of "Roxie" from Chicago. Then we smash cut to "Crazy in Love" and the party begins. Mo'nique and her dancers, all fat and fabulous, power through the choreography and everyone is joining in. Beyonce herself is beaming, and it's impossible not to smile with her. Mo'nique starts her monologue by heaving into the microphone for about a minute. It's daring, it's sexual, Chris Rock wishes he was this dangerous. She tells Usher the dance was "all for you" and all "those skinny video girls" better watch out because they're coming for their jobs. She's a perfect host: bold, fun, and funny.
But you'd have to be pretty bad to mess this night up, because the 2004 BET Awards were the place to be. Black music is always at the center of popular culture. But in 2004, it was really at the center of popular culture. Beyonce, Usher, Outkast, Kanye. Crunk, of all things, became the sound of the moment. Sometimes white people snuck onto the charts, but the likes of Evanescence and Hoobastank were just happy to be there. It didn't last: in 2005 pop music got a whole lot whiter (it also got a whole lot worse. Not a coincidence!). Pop music has rarely been as Black as it was in 2004.
The 2004 BET Awards feel like a celebration of that moment. Everyone is dancing, everyone gets a standing ovation, and everyone sings along to every song. Even in grainy footage on YouTube 20 years after the fact, the vibes are infectious.
And we aren't just celebrating the stars of today! There is a whole 25th Anniversary tribute to hip-hop, featuring pioneers like the Sugarhill Gang, Grandmaster Flash, and Public Enemy. Les Moonves' blacklisting of Janet Jackson post-Super Bowl apparently did not extend to the Paramount-owned BET, and she gives a triumphant and captivating performance here. Outkast's performance of "Roses" is a gorgeous motown tribute with a full '60s style set. It was all great. Forget the Grammys, forget the VMAs. In 2004, it was all here.
2005 SAG Awards
Saturday, February 5, 2005
And now for something much less cool: a union event.
This was...really moving? The highlight of the ceremony is a taped piece celebrating all the less-heralded members of SAG: stunt performers, voice actors, puppeteers, dancers, background actors, and so on. They interview the woman who drove the motorcycle in The Matrix Reloaded's iconic freeway chase, and she's exactly as cool as you'd imagine. They interview the legendary Jim Cummings (voice of Winnie the Pooh and dozens of other iconic characters), and he tells us how people tell him to try "real" acting, and he protests that what he does is real acting. The interviews are filled with such warmth and personality, and the segment celebrates all these people who make movies and TV special but are all too often ignored by the Oscars.
The speeches keep that momentum going. Cate Blanchett recalls how when she moved to America, she was thrilled to discover how strong the actor's union was, and she expresses her hope that other countries can learn from SAG. Tony Shalhoub gives a heartfelt tribute to guest stars, to the specific challenges and joys of coming onto an established show and finding its rhythms. When Jennifer Garner wins for Alias, she thanks both her stunt double and her stand-in by name and recalls how her parents believed she was a real actor when she told them she had health insurance. The late Jerry Orbach, a true actor's actor, wins for Law and Order. His wife Elaine accepts, but the speech is not maudlin or tearful, it's tender and slyly funny. She recalls how much Jerry loved his craft and his community of actors, and how he believed you should "never leave a hit show," always celebrating your good fortune. It's a sentiment that will resonate with the less famous members of the union, and you can tell she knows that.
All in all, it's a proudly pro-union event that sincerely celebrates all the unsung heroes of Hollywood. And it proves that pro-union sentiment is no barrier to creating a terrific show, no matter what the producers of this show might say in 2026. I loved it.
2004 Primetime Emmy Awards
Sunday, September 19, 2004
This is a TV blog, so I can only end with the Emmys.
This received mixed reviews at the time, mostly for host Garry Shandling's performance. But all that survives of this show are speeches on YouTube, and this was a night of great speeches. Even watching them out of order on YouTube, you can feel the energy in the room as they try to top each other, often referencing previous speeches while making their own. Here are the best speeches of the night, ranked.
6- James Spader
He didn't prepare a speech but told everyone they made "excellent choices of shoes and dresses." Gracious, chaotic, with a faint note of perviness. We love you James Spader.
5- Alison Janney
Apparently Janney promised she'd give her Emmy to Mariska Hargitay that she'd give her the Emmy the night before, perhaps while drunk. But she invited her up onstage, and then said she wished she could invite all the nominees up there. Edie Falco, do you want to come up?
Only Hargitay came, but did Alison Janney predict the iconic pageant bit from the 2011 Emmys? Edie Falco got up onstage for that one!
4- Al Pacino
This speech was the inspiration for Bill Hader's Al Pacino impression!
3- Sarah Jessica Parker
She ends with a long list of people to thank as the orchestra plays her off – "and my family and my agent and my publicist and New York City" (great use of polysyndeton!) and concludes with a thank to to "the passers by, who always wanted the best for me!" Wonderful television. Kelsey Grammar later snidely called out the "passers by" line in his own speech. Why? Because it was iconic.
2- Meryl Streep
You might remember the opening. "There are some days when I myself think I'm overrated" (long pause as audience laughs) "but not today." But the whole speech is just as good! The tributes to her fellow nominees (the Glenn Close shoutout that can't help but feel shady, the ribbing of co-star Emma Thompson), the understated and droll thank you to Mike Nichols ("my king"). The orchestra tries to cut her off and she starts singing! She's MERYL STREEP for a reason, you know?
Bonus: Entertainment Tonight puts Meryl's Golden Globes antics on blast in front of her daughter Louisa (the one from The Gilded Age)
1- Elaine Stritch
All those great speeches? They happened because of this one. Elaine Stritch threw down the gauntlet, and everyone had no choice but to try and match her. They didn't, but they all tried. Because this speech was infectious.
It starts well before she gets to the podium. Her winnier reaction is gold, pure joy, vindication, and catharsis. She's motormouthing and milking the crowd the whole way to the podium. Her speech is so raw yet so performative, showing her Broadway roots. She makes the subtext of so many award speeches text. She pays tribute to her nominees before exclaiming, "and I'm so glad none of them won!" She thanks a producer: "I don't like him very much but he got us the money!" She dares producers to literally carry her off the stage, and it feels all the more potent precisely because she is a tiny old woman (so they could carry her off if they wanted to) with a big mouth and a giant personality (so they'd regret it if they tried). She even turns a standard recitation of names into drama. She starts her list with "number one" and then skips to "number three." She gets HBO boss Chris Albrecht's name wrong then corrects herself. I am certain that the words "John Schreiber, Penny Baker, Rick Borutta" have ended up on a Drag Queen's act. At the 2004 Emmys, Elaine Stritch invited us all into her world. For the rest of the night, no one wanted to leave.