5 things I missed: TV seasons

Racing around the world with stops at an LA funeral home and a Reno police department

Share
5 things I missed: TV seasons

Sometimes you miss TV movies or award shows. Sometimes you miss whole seasons of TV. And sometimes you miss three seasons of one show in 12 months.

The Amazing Race season 5

In the summer of 2005, The Amazing Race was a critical darling in danger of being cancelled. Twelve months and three seasons later, it was a huge hit and an Emmy darling. That journey starts with its fifth season, still regarded as its best.

This was just great television. The cast, made up of several teams of two who already know each other, was superb. The show always loved a lovable elderly couple, and "internet dating couple" Bob and Joyce were especially lovable. Daffy twins Kami and Karla would have been a highlight in a different season. And of course there was cousins Charla and Mina, who asked a streetwalker "donde esta la discotequa" and brought drama and entertainment everywhere they went. The image of 4-foot-tall Charla carrying a 55-pound slab of beef will stay with me forever. And "Bowling Moms" Linda and Karen became heroes in a competition where women, and especially older women, are often underestimated. Linda and Karen reached the finale in a very challenging season, and Karen climbing that 150-foot cliff was so iconic. Even the Christian "dating models" Nicole and Brandon ended up being pretty entertaining. His insistence that any situation could be solved with prayer and her exasperation were hilarious.

But in a reality show you need a hero and a villain, and boy did this season deliver with Chip and Kim, a chill and Black couple with a "slow and steady" approach, and especially Colin and Christie, a beauty queen and her very intense boyfriend. It all came to a head in episode 11, "It's Okay, Run them Over!" Reality TV doesn't get much better than this.

Colin and Christie got off to a swimming start at the first challenge in New Zealand. They're counting the money, they can taste the million dollars. You can see it in their eyes. But a missed plane connection leaves them hours behind everyone else. As the episode goes on, they start to lose their minds. It's a glorious fall from grace. They get stuck in traffic and Christie utters the words that give the episode its title to their poor cab driver. The cameramen and producers must have been dancing inside. Then they arrive at a "roadblock" in which Colin has to plow a field before they can continue on. He stumbles through the mud with his ox while Christie shouts instructions from the sidelines and has a total breakdown, finally screaming "my OX is BROKEN! This is BULLSHIT." One of the best TV moments of the entire year.

Six Feet Under Season 4

This had extreme penultimate season energy. The actors are still excellent, and the show can still hit highs. But more infidelity. Claire has more bad relationships. Ruth rushes into a new relationship and regrets it. We'd seen it all before. Some plotlines felt strange and desperate. Why are we stunt-casting Nicole Richie? Ellen DeGeneres plays herself? Why is Keith having sex with a fictional teen pop star played by the late Michelle Trachtenberg? These storylines are regarded as oddities, but it's easy to imagine a world where Six Feet Under ran nine or ten years and these were regarded as the beginning of a decline. But Alan Ball and HBO knew it was time to wrap it up.

This season was panned at the time, but I still found plenty of highlights. I hated Rico's infidelity storyline; his mistress Sophia was such a boring cartoon, and she played into some really ugly stereotypes. But once Vanessa found out, things got good. The finale, when Rico finally apologizes and Vanessa refuses to take him back, was devastating. The parallels between Rico and the ex-wife of that episode's dead person were a little heavy-handed, but Freddy Rodriguez did some of his best work on the show and sold it. The storyline involving Ruth's new husband George (James Cromwell), in which he falls down an internet rabbit hole and becomes obsessed with conspiracy theories and the end of the world, has aged a little strangely. This is supposed to be evidence of his major mental instability, but in 2026 it feels so...normal. But Cromwell and Frances Conroy still find some great stuff in it. I often found Nate's fretting about his wife Lisa's mysterious drowning tiresome, especially when his love interest Brenda (Rahcel Griffiths, perhaps the season MVP) was handling her damage so much better. But the ultimate solution to the Lisa mystery proved very satisfying.

However, this season is best remembered for David's story. Halfway through the season, he gets carjacked in the middle of an episode and effectively tortured for hours. It's a truly upsetting and exhausting watch. Today, this might be a "departure episode," plunging us into the horror. But instead we start a normal episode, cutting back and forth between the whole family. But as David struggles to escape his predicament, we find ourselves trapped there too. You keep on hoping that David will escape and we can go back to Nate or Claire or Ruth, but we don't. He tries to reason with his captor, he tries to escape, but he's powerless. It's brutal. It would feel like a stunt, the show reaching for an Emmy. But the show does a great job portraying the aftermath, the trauma and the way David's loved ones rally around him. The season even ends with a lovely scene of David talking to a vision of his late father, which is lovely (I'm always happy when Richard Jenkins stops by). I also can't help but suspect that this was an attempt to show the audience what it was like to be tortured. This is an overlooked and fascinating piece of the post-9/11 canon.

Amazing Race 6

This season of The Amazing Race is widely despised. Season five was full of likable couples, fans have even come around on villains Colin and Christie. But season six was another story. It seemed cursed. One contestant hit his wife in front of the show's host (CBS' solution was to send them to Dr. Phil for a Primetime special). Perhaps the most likable team, sisters Lena and Christie, were eliminated when they essentially failed to find a needle in a haystack after hours of searching. In fact, almost all the siblings and friends were eliminated early, and we were left with the most annoying straight couples ever.

But I must be a sick, sick person because I enjoyed this season. This was a prime example of what I like to call "heterosexual dysfunction theater." There were the married pro wrestlers, who communicated mostly by yelling at each other and in one memorable challenge drank blood with an alarming lack of hesitation. We had a pair of "engaged models" and a pair of "dating actors," both equally insufferable. There was Adam and Rebecca, "formerly dating" and endlessly fascinating. Television Without Pity recapper Linda Holmes dubbed him "Hornio" due to his memorable hairstyle. He was afraid of everything, she was hot but with a weird sense of humor, she kind of started leading Adam on partway through the season in the hope he'd stop being so useless. They seemed like they were in a lavender marriage. I couldn't help but gawk at these miserable people. Why did they ever get together? Why were they still together?

Part of the fun of The Amazing Race is seeing these relationships tested in trying circumstances. In season six, the producers decided to test all of these tenuous and dysfunctional relationships with some of the nastiest challenges in the show's history. There was the aforementioned "needle in a haystack," challenge, in which contestants spent hours unrolling hay bales searching for a clue. There was a vicious challenge where contestants had to try hundreds of locks, searching for the one that opened with their key. The less stable couples fractured and fizzled under the pressure, I really thought "dating actors" Hayden and Adam would break up and I would have cheered. But just when that seemed imminent, she found the right lock. When they were eliminated, he proposed. I watched in horror.

And there was the infamous soup challenge, in which one contestant had to eat a spicy Hungarian soup that made everyone vomit, their horrifying experience soundtracked by relentlessly cheerful live music. Their partner was supposed to offer encouragement. Except these people mostly berated or shamed their partners. Adam of course stood by and did nothing while Rebecca ate the soup, then held her hair while she puked in the bushes and he imagined their future life together in voiceover. Cinema.

And all this dysfunction was juxtaposed against Kris and John, a couple who had been dating long-distance. They were so obviously in love, so functional, and thrilled to have this experience together after spending so much time apart. They navigated every challenge with sterling teamwork and good humor, the hay bales, the soup, the keys, everything. Standing next to Kris and John, the other couples looked especially tragic and miserable.

In the finale, it really seemed like Kris and John would win. Rebecca and Adam had no chance. Victory was theirs until Adam refused to eat a single deep-dish pizza (seriously?!). Now their main competition was "engaged models" Freddy and Kendra, whose biggest claims to fame were the time he was forced to eat his own puke during the soup challenge (she proved unhelpful during that ordeal) and the time when she was racist towards African children (and the producers just left it in, knowing she'd won!). But Kris and John were blocked by a passing train, and heterosexual dysfunction won the day. The dark ending this season deserved.

Reno 911!

Were it not for this project, I probably never would have stuck with Reno 911! It's a very uneven show; that's inevitable when the whole thing is improvised. It's parodying a show and genre I'm unfamiliar with (Cops and its ilk). But I'm glad I stayed with it.

The show is improvised, cheap, and slapdash by design. But the cast is so good and the premise so solid that you always get a few fun moments every episode. I loved all the fake PSAs scattered throughout, and I loved seeing performers like Wendi McLendon-Covey and Kerri Kenney-Silver get showcase episodes. The weakest episode is unfortunately the biggest showcase for the great Nicey Nash, they try to do a topical episode about Muslims but a mostly improvised show was...not the right venue for that. Definitely not in 2004. It's fun to see future comedy stars in small roles. Simon Helberg appears several times as a tragic nerd; Charlie Day and Mary Elizabeth Ellis play incestuous cousins before Always Sunny was ever picked up.

And in the final two episodes, this show improbably manages to tell an actual serialized story and make a real statement about police corruption. An ambitious local politician decides to prosecute our clownish police officers and we get to see everyone turn on and manipulate each other. You'd have to look to The Wire to find a more cynical portrayal of justice and local politics. Needless to say, it's aged very well.

The Amazing Race 7

The seventh season cemented The Amazing Race as an institution. This was the show's third season in 12 months; they needed something extra to maintain interest. So they cast Survivor sweethearts Rob and Amber.

They made perfect villains. Many people already didn't like Rob due to his antics on Survivor. And as Rob helpfully pointed out in the first episode, they "already won their million" when Amber won Survivor: All Stars; they didn't really need the big Amazing Race prize. Rob and Amber also brought more Survivor-esque tactics to the game. They refused to help other contestants when it didn't suit them, which was frowned upon in Race. More importantly, when faced with one of the show's now-trademark gross food roadblocks, Rob negotiated his way out of it, convincing several other contestants to opt out along with him so he wouldn't have to do it. This effectively killed the extreme eating challenge on the show, which was probably for the best (there was really nowhere to go with it after the soup challenge in season six).

But Rob and Amber proved formidable competitors, largely because their relationship was really solid. We'd seen so many dysfunctional relationships in season six, and season seven had its fair share of those too. But Rob and Amber were always supported each other, they communicated well, and they seemed really happy, defying the stereotypes of reality TV relationships.

Ultimately, fan-favorites Uchenna and Joyce won the day. Critics celebrated, but some wondered if producers were behind a twist of fate that delayed Rob and Amber's plane, clearing the way for Uchenna and Joyce. But the viewers were happy, Uchenna and Joyce were happy. Rob and Amber were happy: they already had their million, they were about to get married, and they were letting CBS turn the whole thing into a May Sweeps primetime special. Everyone was happy, and CBS was probably happiest of all.