Network report card: Fox

From underdog to big dog. Where did Fox stand at the end of the TV season?

Share
Network report card: Fox

With the 2004-5 Network television season coming to a close, I thought I'd do a check-up on all the broadcast networks. This was the most creatively successful, competitive, and exciting broadcast TV season of the 21st century, so there is a lot to talk about. We'll go from first to worst, which means starting with Fox.

Fox launched in 1986. They were the upstart, the bad boy who aired the shows other networks were afraid of. They embraced that image. But how can you be an upstart when you're a winner, the number one network among the all-important 18-49 demographic? You can say that you program bold and dangerous and countercultural shows. But American Idol was the number one show in the country. It was mainstream American culture.

Fox had arrived. But their success would bring more scrutiny and higher stakes. And that success was fragile; their rivals wouldn't let them forget it. Fox was used to challenging the old guard; they thrived as the underdog. Now they had to defend their position at the top of the heap.

We're number 1...

In another year, Fox's historic victory in the ratings race would be the story of the season. But it got lost in the shuffle. ABC's epic comeback and NBC's fall from grace were better stories; Fox's victory received little attention. And it came with caveats. CBS' Les Moonves argued at every opportunity that Fox's victory was whisker-thin and only thanks to the Super Bowl and a historic baseball postseason run. Moonves liked to remind people that if the epic Red Sox vs. Yankees series had been merely six games instead of seven. Meanwhile, NBC eagerly emphasized how close the ratings race was that year. Fox's margin over CBS was small, but so was its margin over last-place NBC.

You might complain about this state of affairs. But Fox didn't. They got to be number one, but without a lot of the pressure or scrutiny that came within. They could still be underdogs if they wanted. +9

All hail the Idol

Other networks had hits. Fox had hits. But there were hits, and then there was American Idol.

Fox aired it only once a year (they had taken to bragging about their restraint after NBC drained much of the life out of The Apprentice with three seasons in 18 months). It arrived every January like a monster, destroying everything in its path. There was a lot of it. Between a record number of audition episodes meant to satisfy America's rapacious appetite for cringe content, the actual performances, and the bloated results show, Fox aired 43 episodes of Idol in 2005. Those episodes routinely commanded over 25 million viewers. It carried them to victory. They had other hits, but without Idol they were nothing.

Idol was at the center of culture, and controversy inevitably followed. One contestant quit the show, seemingly to get out of its famously predatory recording contract, and went on a publicity tour. The Smoking Gun reported on another contestant's history of domestic violence. Another contestant was outed (and he was a teacher! Jesus). Then, real trouble: former contestant Corey Clark detailed his sexual relationship with judge Paula Abdul in an ABC Primetime Live special. With Idol fever sweeping the nation, ratings were high, and coverage was everywhere. But Paula Abdul made fun of the affair on SNL and the contestants and other judges rallied around her on the next Idol episode. The controversy didn't hurt the show at all.

Fox had plenty to celebrate. Their show looked bulletproof. Ratings were growing to impossible new highs. People griped about Carrie Underwood's victory over Bo Bice, but she had the potential to be a gigantic country star. Kelly Clarkson's sophomore album Brekaway had turned her into a real pop star, not a reality show curiosity. Who's to say it couldn't happen again, and again, and again? All hits fade, but Idol was showing no signs of slowing down. +10

Scheduling with Short Stops

Isn't the world series grand? I loved watching it when I was a kid. But baseball always proved a pesky mistress for the people at Fox. It always slashed right through their Fall schedule. There are whole montages on YouTube of Joe Buck hawking forgotten shows during the world series. So many of Fox's best hits launched in the Summer or during midseason: Idol, The OC, Malcolm in the Middle. Everyone was always talking about year-round scheduling. Fox was in a position to make it a reality.

At the 2004 upfronts, Fox announced 4 different schedules for all four seasons. This just confused advertisers. Then all their Summer shows – North Shore, Quintuplets, The Jury – failed to impress critics or audiences. They looked like fools. Fox was still scheduling around postseason baseball, and they still had a couple shows planned for Summer (the cooking reality show Hell's Kitchen and the serial killer thriller The Inside). But they'd learned their lesson, they weren't making any grand promises, but they'd planned some changes for midseason when Idol would return. -3

America's Pastime

Baseball always destroyed Fox's schedule. But it's worth it because sometimes you get a series like the 2004 Red Sox vs. Yankees mashup. Now that was exciting television. And it was lucrative television for Fox. +3

24 episodes straight

One scheduling gambit that did work was moving 24 to midseason so it could run for 22 weeks stright through without repeats. The show was looking pretty long in the tooth after three seasons, multiple world-ending disasters, and a cougar chase. And there was a darker reason to move 24: this put some distance between a new season of the "torture show" and the Abu Gharaib scandal.

They launched the new season after a postseason football game, premiered episodes after American Idol auditions, promoted the season with a terrific super-bowl spot, and before long their flagging show was reinvigorated. No repeats made a huge difference, this is not a show that benefits from long waits between episodes of lots of time to ponder the plausibility of literally anything that happens. They received major pushback from the Muslim community due to a "terrorists among us!" storyline ripped straight from the paranoid fantasies of Fox News; they had to add a sub-plot, meet with interest groups, and film some PSAs. But it didn't slow them down. The season was regarded as a creative rebound and it ended very strong. People were excited for day five. +9

A Late Night Dream Dies

Fox's first-ever original program was a late night talk show starring Joan Rivers. In the years since, they'd tried to start a Late Night Franchise several times: Chevy Chase flamed out, negotiations with Arsenio Hall fell apart, and no one even remembers Wilton North.

In 2001, got serious about courting Conan O'Brien. His young, cool, male audience was a good fit for Fox. Conan got his start as a writer on Fox's signature hit The Simpsons, after all. They promised to make him the face of the network and quintuple his pay. But a 20-year-old network couldn't offer him the one thing he really wanted: the show he watched with his dad as a child. They couldn't give him The Tonight Show. They couldn't give him Johnny Carson's chair.

In 2004, Conan finalized his deal to take over the Tonight Show. Jay Leno would remain at the job for five more years, and then Conan would get that chair. In September, they made it public.

Fox was number one, they were established. But they weren't one of the big three. They didn't have a morning show (their attempt, Fox After Breakfast, was an infamous disaster). They didn't have a network news division, daytime soaps, or talk shows. Their daytime programming was limited to kids' shows and sports; late night programming was limited to MadTV. The full court press was the last time they ever tried to expand beyond that. When he passed, their ambitions became smaller. They'd arrived, but they didn't need to push their luck. Not with cable and the internet competing for everyone's attention. A wise decision, in retrospect. -1

After Idol

Having the biggest show on TV is great. 25 million people were watching Idol every week. Surely they could get some of them to watch whatever they put on after it.

But that's harder than it looks. It should have been easy to get people to stick around for half an hour after the results show. These people were watching Ryan Seacrest stall for time in a sea of product placement week after week, how discerning could they be? And it's not like there was anything else one. Yes, Dear? The second half of Law and Order? But The Simple Life, the sitcoms Stacked and Hot Dog on a Stick. People weren't impressed by the spooky soap Point Pleasant either. -7

But American Idol still proved its power. When House premiered in November critics feared it was doomed. It was so dark (a pill popping doctor, imagine!) and so smart! How could it survive on broadcast? The ratings didn't inspire much hope. But Fox put it after Idol in the new year and boom. Smash hit. +9

When Ty Pennington Attacks!

Fox was famous for its sensational feel-bad reality programming, much of it courtesy of Mike Darnell. Alien Autopsy, Temptation Island, When Animals Attack! The season prior The Swan had been a hit for the network. But "women get plastic extensive plastic surgery then compete against each other in a beauty pageant" wasn't something most of America wanted to see twice. My Big Fat Obnoxious Boss proved equally uninspiring, as did My Big Fat Obnoxious Fiance. Fox rushed a boxing reality show onto the air in an attempt to beat NBC's The Contender, it flopped. Mike Darnell's TV special in which an adopted woman had to choose her biological father from a lineup of eight contenders drew outrage from the adoption community and disgust from others.

By 2005, the hottest new trend was feel good reality TV. Some of this stuff was just as nasty as a Mike Darnell special when you pulled back the curtain, but viewers felt like it was good for them. Watch these people get their dream house on Extreme Makeover: Home Edition! Watch these people work together and travel the world on The Amazing Race! Watch people from different walks of life understand eachother on Wife Swap! Watch this British lady teach people how to parent on Supernanny! Fox actually had two moderately successful copycats of the latter two shows (Trading Spouses and Nanny 911!) but people preferred the originals on ABC. Fox had the crown jewel of reality TV, but were they losing their touch?

On the other hand, Hell's Kitchen was premiering in just a few days. Fox still had their touch. -3

Stalwart Saturdays

By 2005, everyone had abandoned Saturdays. It was a place for reruns and the occasional show you wanted to burn off in the utmost obscurity,. But Saturdays were rock solid for Fox. Their lineup of COPS, America's Most Wanted, and MADtv had remained unchanged since 1996. It would remain unchaged until 2011. That's what I call stability. +5

Bowl Me Over

When your network has the biggest program of the year, you better make it count. Fox did. They promoted their best shows during the game, with the 24 spot being a particular highlight. And while the American Dad sneak preview after the game was greeted with a shrug, it proved a big hit for the network; they're still producing new episodes today. And it probably helped build trust with Seth McFarlane, a good thing in the long run. +7

Thursday, here we come

The big news for Fox in the fall of 2004 was The OC's move to Thursdays. With Friends gone, Fox decided to stake their claim on televisions' most profitable night. It went well. The OC's audience did not grow, and the show suffered a sophomore slump. But the viewers stayed loyal. Now if only they had something to pair it with. Viewers rejected supernatural soap Point Pleasant and the second season of Tru Calling. +4

The '70s might be over

Fox's reliable sitcom That '70s Show finished the season with its future in serious doubt, as stars Topher Grace and Ashton Kutcher left after finding success in movies. -3

You'll Always Have Paris

Fox's The Simple Life was probably never built to last, but the end of stars Paris Hilton and Nicole Ritchie spelled doom for the show, with Ritchie exiting the project. Before long the show moved to E! -3

Welcome Back, Family Guy

Fox gave TV fans across the globe unfounded hope when they brought Family Guy back from the dead three years after they cancelled it. Reruns on Adult Swim, DVD sales, and torrenting sites (animated shows were popular because the files were smaller and downloaded faster) had helped the show find new fans. (Young, male, fans, Hollywood's favorite kind). Fox bet on those new fans and it paid off. The revival was a hit, a solid addition to Fox's storied Sunday animation block. Seth McFarlane's new show American Dad received a sneak preview after the super bowl and was turning into a solid hit airing after Family Guy. Much to celebrate for fox and Family Guy. Just don't go thinking this means your favorite show will meet the same fate. +8

A Change in Leadership

Gail Berman was the entertainment president at Fox starting in 2000. She developed most of the networks biggest hits: American Idol, 24, The OC, and House. Before that, her production company Recency Television produced Malcolm in the Middle and The Bernie Mac Show, two more hits for Fox. Fox climbed to number one because of her.

Paramount Pictures was impressed, and hired her to run their movie studio, though she stayed for just two years and remains best known for her work in television. Peter Liguori, who helped run Fox's cable networks including FX, replaced her. Gail Berman gave him a few parting gifts though – Hell's Kitchen, Bones, and Prison Break – some of the last shows developed under her tenure. Liguori needed those gifts, he did not have Berman's eye for hits. -2

Arrested Ratings

People think Fox tried to kill Arrested Development. Understandable, I can't imagine the Murdoch's were fans. But it's not true. Fox gave Arrested the best time slot possible, after The Simpsons. I watch a lot of old ad packages for this project. Trust me, the show received plenty of promotion.

Many people hoped that all that, plus a recent Emmy for best comedy series, would drive ratings up. It wasn't to be. The second season of Arrested Development is also quite uneven and weaker than the first, though still filled with iconic moments.

Fans of the show were on death-watch, especially after the network cut the episode order back from 11 to 18 episodes. Then Gail Berman, the show's most powerful champion, left the company. But Fox saved it. The amount of goodwill they earned from critics and reporters was extraordinary. +3

Malcolm & Bobby

I'm trying to stick to the business side of things here but both these shows had very good seasons and some true masterpiece episodes this year and nobody cared! Anyway, stream "Pearl Harbor" and "Bobby on Track." They didn't get the love they deserved in 2005 but we can fix that now. +5

Ratings Points (new shows receive double points)

Shows in the Nielsen top 5 (5 points each)

American Idol Tuesdays, American Idol Wednesdays 10 points

Shows ranked 20th-30th (1 point each)

House 2 points NEW

Sweeps won (3 points each)

February, May 6 points

End of Season Placement

1st out of 6 networks: 6 points

Appointment television, for me (2 points each)

Arrested Development, Malcolm in the Middle, King of the Hill, The OC, 24 10 points

I drop in sometimes (1 point each)

The Bernie Mac Show, House NEW, American Idol 4 points

FINAL SCORE: 87 points

FINAL GRADE: B+