What was on TV? Fri, May 20, 2005

The Daytime Emmys, the Muppets follow the yellow brick road. Plus Avatar and the WB upfront.

Share
What was on TV? Fri, May 20, 2005

In May 2005, the last Star Wars movie was released around the world. Back then, that really was the end! Let's see what was on TV.

8:00 Avatar: The Last Airbender on Nickelodeon

1x11 "The Great Divide" (record "The Muppets' Wizard of Oz" on ABC"

Kids' TV has a bad reputation and episodes like this are a big part of the reason why. Ang and the gang need to cross this universe's version of the Grand Canyon with two warring tribes of refugees. Why can't they just get along? They have so much in common! Turns out their conflict just stems from a giant century-old misunderstanding, how about that. And since Ang was actually alive back then, he can clear it up. It was literally a children's game. And if those kids could set aside their differences, they can too. And they do it, easy peasy. All it took was one speech from a kid. Except twist! Ang made it all up! And don't those tribes look stupid.

This is so pat. TV show tells kids that we're all the same really and fighting is stupid. But this episode was produced during the war on terror. Many people thought that the real problem with the war on terror was that the people we were invading couldn't get along with each other. If the Sunnis and Shiites and Kurds could just get along we could help them help themselves, easy peasy! This episode endorses that asinine idea, and in this context Ang's lie is genuinely rank. It's so condescending, so presumptuous. I hated it.

9:00 Daytime Emmy Awards on CBS

The Daytime Emmys have a different energy. They're not like the fancy award shows, where the industry literally applauds itself since everyone in the audience is part of the industry. It's not like the VMAs, where the audience is filled with fans, but only telegenic fans, all eager to be cool. The Daytime Emmys audience is full of the most hardcore fans, and they are SCREAMING for their favorite soap stars and talk show types. Television breeds a unique sort of intimacy, and daytime television most of all. Daytime stars are in people's home, every day, for years, even decades. Fans and stars literally grow old together. There's nothing like it.

Daytime stars know they'll never have the same respect as primetime or the silver screen. But their audiences adore them, and the best daytime stars adore and respect that audience right back. They aren't primetime, but the people on that stage know they work harder and are better loved than almost anyone else in the industry. The Daytime Emmys are a place to celebrate that knowledge, and it is glorious.

This entire ceremony is so idiosyncratic and delightful. Outstanding younger actor winner David Lago does an impression of Christopher Walken's mice speech from Catch Me If You Can and it is somehow very fitting and even moving. Outstanding younger actress winner Eden Riegel is the picture perfect ingenue, thanking the universe for all the previous losses that helped her appreciate the win and confessing she plans to give her trophy to her grandmother. All My Children legend David Canary presents the kids' TV awards from inside a trash can with Oscar the Grouch. The montages for the Drama series nominees...every single award show needs to take notes. Lacrimosa and "Bring Me To Life" score the most iconic kisses, slaps, disrobing, reaction shots for each series. The crowd goes wild every time. Simon Cowell brings out Il Divo to salute the best actress nominees in song, a promotional move so brilliant I was forced to hard it to Simon Cowell, who I hate. (Many wonder who the market was for an international boy band singing "Unchained Melody" in Italian, but the market was literally the Daytime Emmys audience). There's even a tie! It's such a great show. There is so much good humor throughout; the vibes are immaculate. It wasn't all so sunny under the surface (Ellen DeGeneres' two wins are a potent reminder of that). But watching this ceremony, I truly believed in the strength and power of this community.

(As always, a huge thank you to the person who uploaded this broadcast to YouTube. But please be advised that the audio is wildly out of sync for much of the middle part of the broadcast.

11:00 The Wonderful World of Disney: The Muppets' Wizard of Oz (recorded)

It's shameful, but it's true: this is the first full-length Muppet movie I've seen. And clearly this is not their finest hour. The humor is not clever or whimsical. You can tell this was produced in the aftermath of Shrek, there's a lot of topical "references" in place of jokes. Girls Gone Wild, Kabbalah, a Tarantino cameo, and so on. But at least Shrek delivers fun bathroom humor gags to keep kids (and let's face it, the adults) entertained. This movie can't even do that. The songs are bad. I am an Ashanti truther but her performance as Dorothy is bad too. Some of the Hollywood satire is good. There's a dark joke involving a "makeover machine" and some unintentional moments of black comedy involving Jeffrey Tambor as the wizard. The Hollywood satire has real resonance given that this was the Muppets' first major project after Disney bought them out, and given Disney's ongoing struggle to do much of anything with Kermit and the gang. It's enough to make you wish this was a really good movie, or at least a really strange satire with teeth. But it is neither.

What Else Was On

  • In a special primetime episode, Dr. Phil yelled at a woman who was addicted to pills.
  • The Fox Friday Night movie was Shallow Hal.
  • On 20/20, Elizabeth Vargas investigated the truth behind Jesus Christ's resurrection.
  • On the season finale of What I Like About You, titled "Enough is Enough, Part 2 of 3" – can Amanda Bynes tell Nick Zano she loves him before it's too late? All questions will be answered this fall in "Enough is Enough, Part 3."

Late Night

Ted Danson was living every Dad's dream in 2005. He spends most of his Conan interview talking about Martha's Vineyard. He is wifeguy-maxxing so hard that he plugs his wife Mary Steenburgen's store multiple times (Montana Ave. in Santa Monica!). The Showtime Original movie about sexual abuse in the Church he's supposed to be promoting (he plays Stanley Tucci from Spotlight!)? Not important. He goes on a long tangent about unpacking boxes in the back of Steenburgen's store. Conan comments that he seems so zen he's worried about his heartrate.

Then, after the commercial, he participates in a film noir parody sketch about how boring his life is. Like I said, every Dad's dream.

At the WB Upfront...

The WB was supposed to beat UPN! The WB was cool, UPN was its sad loser cousin with an identity crisis. But in 2005, UPN had momentum. They had hits, they had buzz, and they had better ratings. It was like something out of a WB show: people grow tired of the hunky lead and suddenly his quirky cousin looks a lot more attractive.

The WB was struggling. All of their new shows had fizzled. They had developed a few solid hits in recent years, but the last time they developed a creative and commercial hit was Everwood, way back in 2001. Meanwhile, the buzziest and most acclaimed teen shows were on other networks. The OC was on Fox, Veronica Mars and America's Next Top Model were on UPN, Laguna Beach was on MTV. Reality was the most popular genre among the WB's core audience, yet all of the WB's attempts at the genre had failed. It was the sole broadcast network without a signature reality hit. It was time to change things up.

The previous network president had been axed, and now it was up to David Janollari to turn things around. He had two major strategies. First, he declared his intentions age up the WB's audience. The kids who watched Dawson's Creek were in college now, some of them had even graduated. Second, he leaned heavily on powerful and proven producers. The WB picked up shows from Jerry Bruckheimer, Tom Fontana, McG, David E. Kelly, and Will and Grace creators Max Mutchnick and David Kohan. It reeked of insecurity, like they needed the validation of these big-time names. The WB still felt like a network in crisis. And in a little more than a year, it wouldn't be a network at all.

TiVo Status

1 episode of Mystery! 1 hour.