What was on TV? Mon, May 23, 2005

Tom Cruise has a fateful chat with Oprah. 24, Everwood, and Girlfriends say see you next season.

Share
What was on TV? Mon, May 23, 2005

On May 23, 2005, Tom Cruise jumped on Oprah's couch. Let's see what else was on TV.

8:00 24 on Fox

4x23 "5:00 AM - 6:00 AM" and 4x24 "6:00 AM - 7:00 AM" (record Everwood on the WB and Girlfriends on UPN)

I'm not always on board with 24, both morally and artistically. But I was powerless to resist these two hours. Maybe it's because the show goes all in on romance, and I can never resist a good romance. Even though I only met them halfway through this season, these past few episodes made me care about Michelle and Tony. And when Tony was kidnapped right as they got back together! It's shameless, but the actors made it work, I was fretting right along with Michelle.

This episode also marks the return of a classic 24 villain, an assassin played by Mia Kirshner. And boy is she ever a jolt of energy. The brings so much life and specificity to this stock 24 archetype. There's another assassin sent to kill Jack Bauder himself in the final act of the finale but he just doesn't have the sauce.

So many other great moments! The look on Dennis Haysbert's face as he okays a full pardon for Mia, who tried to assassinate him. Habib Marwan's death! He was such a great villain, they needed to deliver an iconic death and they didn't disappoint. Marwan trying to jump off a building rather than give up the location of the nuke, only for Jack to grab his hand, only for Marwan to take out a knife and slice Jack's hand open, forcing him to let go and watch Marwan fall to his death. That's drama! Jack walking into a perfectly orange California sky like a true action hero. There wasn't enough Edgar and Chloe but other than that, this is everything I wanted in a 24 finale. And I'm ashamed to want anything from a 24 finale. But what can I say? Despite everything, the show is good. That's why it was dangerous.

10:00 Everwood (recorded)

3x22 "Where the Heart Is"

In the season one finale of Everwood, we saw Andy Brown leave the operating room. We lingered on the faces of the community he'd become a part of and the son whose trust he'd earned back. But we didn't know if he'd been able to save Colin. Would be be the godlike hero again? Or would Colin's death and his failure change his relationship to these people forever?

In season two, we saw Andy made a terrible choice, believing he was protecting his son. The final scene was him remembering his late wife, and wondering if he had changed at all, if he was still governed by pride.

In the season three finale of Everwood: Andy tells Nina he loves her. But oh no! There's Jake! Who will she choose?

This is not what I want from an Everwood season finale. Leave this stuff to One Tree Hill. The previous two season finales were haunting, ambivalent, gorgeous, sad, and totally unlike anything else on television. This is so pedestrian by comparison. It feels like a network note. What a bummer.

Later Girlfriends (recorded)

5x22 "...With a Twist"

There are two many boys in this episode Girlfriends. Maya is busy getting back together with her ex-husband, Lynn is busy breaking up with the fuckboy musician, and Joan is busy hooking up with William. And we don't get to see the girls being friends, which is the whole point of the show! Toni is having her baby and no one is there for her; she has to get advice from a nosy nurse. I was pissed. This better not become a trend.

About Oprah, Tom Cruise, and that couch...

I'm so annoyed there's no footage of this episode. Watching moments like this in context is what this entire project is about! The best I can find is a four-minute highlight reel in which he does indeed jump onto the couch. (He never jumped up and down on it like a kid at a sleepover. But there was jumping).

Even in clips, you can tell that the audience was absolutely feral for him. A backlash to Cruise and his relationship with Katie Holmes was already brewing, but not among these women. Cruise clearly feeds off their energy, and commits 100% to giving them what they want. He knows what these women want to hear: that he's in love! So he goes all the way, with full commitment and intensity. That's what makes him such a great movie star. Watch him command a totally different audience at the previous year's MTV Movie Awards. This was no different. He was in his element here.

But the world had changed, and he wasn't ready. No one was. YouTube had launched about a month ago, Perez Hilton's blog and the Huffington Post were both a few weeks old. And Tom gave them all exactly what they needed. They used the interview as a jumping-off point to speculate about his relationship with Holmes (was it fake?) and about Tom Cruise's persona, personal life, and religion. You could post the photo of him standing on the couch at the top of the article. He really did seem crazy. The clicks followed. Soon mainstream news sources and late-night shows were referencing that time when Tom Cruise went crazy on Oprah. And if you missed the episode and wanted to see it for yourself, all you had to do was type "Tom Cruise goes Crazy" into Google and you might find a clip on some mysterious website called "YouTube." Someone else mashed a short clip where Tom grabbed Oprah's hands with lightning effects Star Wars; the newest film had just been released in theaters. "Tom Cruise kills Oprah" became an internet meme.

Thus, the most private and controlling movie star of all learned that you can't control anything in the age of the internet. And unfortunately for Cruise, he was uniquely ill-equipped to deal with the aftermath. We'll explore why in the weeks to come.

What Else Was On

  • ABC turned Newlyweds Jessica Simpson and Nick Lachey's USO tour in Iraq into a TV special. Also appearing: Jimmy Kimmel, Willie Nelson, and Brian McKnight. The very next day, news of their People reported that they'd filed for divorce. They denied the rumors then filed for divorce a month later.
  • On the season finale of CSI: Miami: David Caruso's brother Dean Winters is back from the dead!

24 Alternatives to 24

#5: The Hidden Blade and My Beautiful Enemy by Sherry Thomas

As I discussed in my review, this episode of 24 was surprisingly romantic. And it also trafficked in Sinophobia, threatening Jack Bauer with a terrible fate in the custody of Big Bad China. So I'm going to recommend a romance series starring two spies and set in China.

That description doesn't do justice to these books. Thomas combines tropes from classic children's literature, wuxia dramas, spy thrillers, romance novels and more to create something totally new. The Hidden Blade follows two pre-teens on opposite sides of the globe. Lee is an orphan under the thumb of his evil uncle in Edwardian England. Ying-ying is the daughter of a courtesean living in Peking and receiving secret lessons in the art of wuxia. Each child grows up, encountering friends and villains. In My Beautiful Enemy, they meet and fall in love.

These books are action-packed. There are truly scary and hateable villains. Thomas also excels at writing complex parent-child and mentor-mentee relationships. These books contain enough stunning twists, shocking deaths, tender yearning, and heart-stopping moments to power and entire 22 or 24 episode season of television.

Blogs, circa 2005

If you want a taste of Oprah's power in the aughts, look to the slam poetry of Rosie O'Donnell:

oprah is a hybrid human
i am sure
decades from now
they will exhumne her remains
and find the dna
of the rest of us
in the future
evolved
this makes no sense
i called oprah
right after columbine
crying
the kind of desperate dial
u reserve for those closest to you
i don’t know oprah
she is a goddess
i am sure
meeting her confirmed
something
i try to run from
me
“are you going to spend another summer fat”
she asked us all last week
i am afraid so
yes
am i the only woman
who does not watch
desperate housewives
real housewives
are so much more interesting
2 me
peace out

Rosie wasn't the only one who felt that way. Millions of people would decide that the "Real Housewives" of Orange County, New York City, Atlanta, and beyond were more interesting than the desperate housewives of Wisteria Lane.

Tivo Status

2 episodes of Mystery! 2 hours.