What was on TV? Monday, May 30, 2005

Hell's Kitchen is a manifestation of America's colonial shame. Summer is the time to make arguments like this, okay? Plus Romy and Michele say Trans rights?

Share
What was on TV? Monday, May 30, 2005

In May 2005, people were waiting 40 hours for their pirated copy of Revenge of the Sith to download.

8:00 Romy and Michele: In the Beginning on ABC Family

I love a crazy TV movie. But this one just made me sad. Traces of the original Romy and Michele are present in this made-for-TV prequel. Robin Schiff, who wrote the original film, writes and directs this one. The same offbeat humor and point of view that animated the original is there. It's also daring, just like that first movie. It takes swings with tone and subject matter. They just don't land this time. A movie like this is all about tone. The director, the actors, the writer, everyone has to get it just right. That didn't happen here.

The biggest problem is Katherine Heigl and Alexandra Breckinridge as Romy and Michele, respectively. But they were in a no-win situation here. We've seen Mira Sorvino and Lisa Kudrow play these characters before and after the events of this movie, so they kind of have to do an imiation. This is especially tough for Heigl, who just cannot nail that Voice, but who could? Her mannerisms also reminded me so powerfully of Izzie Stevens (she probably shot this while she was waiting for Grey's Anatomy to get picked up. It's very uncanny.

There are also bizarre attempts at progressivism. Its heart is definitely in the right place, but it just does not land. There is a trans character, a cool maternal landlord type, and she's even played by a trans actress (Alexandra Billings in one of her first major roles). She has bottom surgery and a party to celebrate it and everything. But the plotline where the girls' cute neighbors (Nat Faxon and another guy) mistake them for trans men just misses the mark. Another storyline involving a Latina maid with hidden singing talent is also made me cringe.

Anyway, Rhea Seahorn plays a mean girl and Paula Abdul appears as herself. Wild movie!

Hell's Kitchen on Fox

1x01 "Day 1"

The effects of colonization really do last forever. If anyone could leave their colonizers behind, it would be the United States of America. By the 21st century, they had long since surpassed Britain in the world order, largely by colonizing other places and peoples. They had also surpassed Britain in the more nebulous world of global pop culture. If any wounds were going to heal, it would be these ones.

But no! Look no further than the first wave of American reality television, which revealed that Americans harbor a deep and primal desire to be yelled at by a British person. First came American Idol, which became the biggest thing in the country largely because Americans like watching Simon Cowell tell their countrymen that they couldn't sing. In 2005, Fox took this formula to the kitchen with British TV star Gordon Ramsay's first American series, Hell's Kitchen. The fact that Gordon Ramsay was Scottish and working class, and thus had much better reasons to resent the British elite than his American audience? Didn't matter. The fact that we were looking to the United Kingdom, famous for its terrible food, as an authority on cooking? Not important. Americans yearned for a stern British man.

Ramsay does plenty of yelling at the contestants in the first episode. He spits out at least half their dishes and has almost nothing nice to say. But most reviewers at the time latched onto a moment when he calls two customers "bimbos" and tells someone to "escort them back to plastic surgery." That says a lot! I suppose that in 2005, America felt like shit, and we wanted our British forefathers to validate us.

Let's launch a presidential campaign!

George Bush's second term wasn't even a year old, but Republicans were already preparing for the next election. They had their work cut out for them. Bush's war was unpopular and his plan to privatize Social Security was unpopular. Things seemed unlikely to improve. But Republicans thought they had a winning candidate in War Hero-turned Senator John McCain. A TV movie inspired by his time as a POW in Vietnam proved an opportunity to test the waters.

The actual movie isn't very interesting, though it does star The Pitt's Shawn Hatosy as McCain (Scott Glenn plays his dad, and Shea Whigham plays his fellow POW). The movie's promotion is a lot more interesting. McCain went on Fox and Friends, where he received glowing coverage as a war hero and a bipartisan deal-maker. Then he went on Late Night with Conan O'Brien where he...received glowing praise as a war hero and bipartisan deal-maker. On another Fox News program, they literally described him as a "maverick," seeding the rhetoric that would drive McCain's campaign three years later. I can see why they were confident. The Republican president was unpopular; McCain was #NotLikeOtherRepublicans.be was bipartisan, people love that! Even people who disagree with him are impressed by his bravery in Vietnam! Look, even Conan, avatar of the cool kids, likes him.

It's fascinating to watch this happen in real time. I suspect that in the coming years I'll see a similar testing of the waters from the Hilary and Obama camps.

What Else Was On

  • Cartoon Network premiered The Life and Times of Juniper Lee, created by former Real World contestant Judd Winick. Now he writes the ultra-popular kids' graphic novel series Hilo.
  • Natalie Glebova of Canada won the Miss Universe Pageant.

TV news, circa 2005

Piracy exploded in 2005. Television Week had the details:

Illegal downloading of TV shows has soared in the past 16 months, with a 368 percent increase from January 2004 to April 2005. Those numbers come from Big Champagne, an online measurement firm that tracks activity on peer-to-peer networks that share copies of TV shows on the Internet. The amount of content traded on peer-to-peer networks has increased 17 percent since February alone, according to the firm.
The six sites targeted by MPAA together facilitate the illegal swapping of copyrighted material to more than 100,000 people daily, according to MPAA.
Animated shows are popular because their file size is smaller. In April nearly 448,000 copies of "The Simpsons" could be found on popular file-sharing networks at any given time, said Eric Garland, CEO of Big Champagne. Mr. Garland described his company's service as "similar to a Nielsen television audience measure."
Next on the list of most-pirated shows was Fox's "American Idol," with about 446,000 active copies, followed by Fox's "Family Guy" at 429,000. Also in the top 10 were ABC's "Desperate Housewives," Fox's "The O.C." and CBS's "CSI."