What was on TV? Sat, May 21, 2005
Lohan's at 30 Rock! Also in NYC: the UPN upfront
In May 2005, Lindsey Lohan was determined to live her life (just not the way we or the Walt Disney company wanted her to). Let's see what was on TV.

11:30 Saturday Night Live! on NBC
30x20 host Lindsey Lohan with musical guest Coldplay
This is the second of four episodes hosted by Lindsey Lohan. There's some sad lore attached to it, as it is rumored that the cast staged an unsuccessful intervention for Lohan (who was by this point seriously struggling with addiction and bulimia) after the episode. They would try again when she hosted in 2006, again without success.
I can see why they kept trying. Fey, Poehler, and Lorne Michaels had worked with her on Mean Girls and seen that she was not merely a child star or a tabloid fixture, she was a born comedienne with great instincts. Lohan is a great SNL host. She is willing to make fun of herself. Time has rendered her monologue duet with Amy Poelher as her future self quite sad, and yet it's still funny because the writing is sharp and she's game. She can play crazy characters (tonight she has to play a nutty Italian American wife). Best of all, she's a great straight woman. The straight man is the most valuable archetype in SNL, and it's a real boon when you can not only use the host in that rule, but when they prove funny in that role to boot. Her best sketch is an ANTM parody, where she plays the fresh-faced blonde. She just nails the "aw shucks" archetype, threatening to outshine Maya Rudolph as Tyra and Tina Fey as Janice Dickinson. It's a reminder of what a talent she was, and why people still mourn what could have been.
What Else Was On
- Tonight's episode of 48 Hours is titled "Two Wigs, a Gun, and a Murder." You have my attention.
- On the Sci-Fi channel, Luke Perry battles volcanoes in this Saturday's original movie Descent.
- Showtime premiered a movie about the Geoghan case, which will be familiar to anyone who's seen Spotlight. This movie focused more directly on It starred Ted Danson as Mitchell Garabedian (played by Stanley Tucci in Spotlight) and Christopher Plummer as Cardinal Law.
At the UPN upfront...
At the 2005 Upfronts, the show everyone was talking about was Everybody Hates Chris, a family sitcom produced by Chris Rock and inspired by his own childhood in Brooklyn. It was the only show to receive a truly enthusiastic response from critics or advertisers all week. And this show wasn't on ABC, it wasn't on NBC, it wasn't on Fox, it wasn't on CBS. It was on UPN.
UPN was a joke. It still is, two decades after the network went dark. It launched in 1993, the same year as the WB. But the WB quickly found its brand as a teen network, UPN suffered from a perpetual identity crisis. As recounted by Cynthia Littleton in the excellent book Season Finale, UPN tried being a network for Star Trek fans, it tried being a network for middle America, it tried being the WB. Nothing worked. The only thing that did work was its consistent roster of Black sitcoms. But these were often dismissed by critics and White tastemakers, sometimes for good reason (Homeboys from Outer Space, The Secret Diary of Desmon Pfeiffer) and sometimes for racist reasons (Girlfriends, The Parkers, One on One). And UPN was always hesitant to embrace its image as a Black network. The advertisers who go to upfronts won't pay top dollar to hawk their wares on a Black network.
But Black people still saw UPN as a Black network, and Chris Rock was no exception. That's why he agreed to take his show to UPN after Fox passed on it – and after a strident campaign by UPN boss Dawn Ostroff. Ostroff was all in on Chris. WWE Smackdown, a longtime UPN staple, was booted to Fridays and Chris would lead off a Thursday comedy block. It was smart programming. Counterprogramming aimed at Black audiences had worked back in the days of Mist-See-TV when Living Single thrived opposite Friends on Fox. And thanks to the collapse of Must See TV, there wasn't much comedy on Thursdays (or on any day of the week). It wasn't such a stretch to imagine that sitcom fans would abandon Joey or the aging Will and Grace for Chris. And by all appearances, they were standing by their loyal Black audience, adding another hour of Black sitcoms (the reality was more complicated and ugly, but that's a story for another day).
And it wasn't just Chris. UPN had plenty to celebrate. Britney Spears' home videos had earned record ratings for the network, and Ostroff celebrated by taking the upfront stage at Madison Square Garden with a snake around her neck and annoucing that "the days of this network suffering from multiple personality disorder are over". Critical darling Veronica Mars had survived, and they planned a "Summer of Veronica" campaign to boost its ratings. America's Next Top Model was still strong. They unveiled their new slogan: "where the girls are and the boys want to be." Chris Rock joked that it sounded like the motto for a strip club. Compared to the jokes leveled at UPN in past years, it was almost a compliment.
Music, circa 2005
It's from 2004, but I don't think I've ever posted Lindsey Lohan's eternal banger "Rumors," so let me rectify that.
TiVo Status
1 episode of Mystery! 1 hour.