What was on TV? Sun, May 22, 2005
A wedding, an unpleasant surprise, death, gunplay, and more on the season finales of Deadwood, Grey's Anatomy, and Desperate Housewives
On May 22, 2005 Laura Bush visited Jerusalem and got heckled by Israelis and Palestinians. Let's see what was on TV.

9:00 Deadwood on HBO
2x12 "Boy the Earth Talks To" (record Desperate Housewives on ABC and Mystery! on PBS
A wedding, a murder, friendship, deceit, stretches and breathing exercises, and tortured, longing looks across the room. That's Deadwood. That's America. And that's television, baby.
In the coming years, TV would become more and more addicted to shocking finale moments as the attention economy swallowed us all. And I love a big shocking finale moment; this year delivered some great ones. But there's something to be said for the quieter approach. Here is a hall-of-fame HBO drama underplaying its big finale murder, its big finale new character, and even the big finale wedding. And it's brilliant. Television could use a little more of that. It would help you stand out. And we all need to stand out in the attention economy.
Really, when you think about it, the arrival of MySpace and social media in 2005 is a lot like the arrival the railroad in Deadwood in 1877.

10:00 Grey's Anatomy on ABC
1x09 "Who's Zoomin' Who?"
This wasn't supposed to be the finale. Grey's Anatomy had 13 episodes in the can, but ABC only had time to air 9 of them before the season wrapped up. Maybe in another world they would have burned them off in the summer, but Grey's was just too successful. So the ninth episode became the season finale.
This isn't a classic Grey's season finale. No grand declarations, tragic deaths, or dramatic disasters here. Instead, we get wacky subplots about an unauthorized autopsy and a syphilis outbreak.
But that final twist still holds up. Critics dismissed it as predictable back in the day. But it certainly hooked audiences and got people talking. All these years later, the cliffhanger still makes me excited. And not because I don't know what's coming next, but because I do. This twist rules because it brings the core themes of Rhimes' work into focus and announces her as a true TV auteur. The role of the mistress, which she would take even further in Scandal. But more broadly: unequal and imbalanced relationships. She's already explored the complications of dating your boss several times this season, and she will double down in season two and beyond. But we also see an imbalance of trust in this episode. Meredith tells Derek her secret; she tells him about her mother's Alzheimers. And she's told no one about this, not even her best friends. Derek kept this a secret until it was too late. That's the real betrayal of that final twist.

11:00 Desperate Housewives (recorded)
1x23 "One Wonderful Day"
This was a good finale. It was suspenseful; the actors were on top of their game. The solutions to the mystery was obvious but well-dramatized. Susan trapped in the house with Zach was properly scary. Gabrielle, Carlos, and John's courtroom confrontation was delightfully absurd. Mike and Paul Young's standoff in the desert was dramatic and much enhanced by the setting, shoutout to the locaction scouts. We even got some good Edie moments.
There are lots of good moments in this episode, but only one truly great one. The scene where Bree learns that her husband died captures everything that made this show a phenomenon. Bree picks up the phone and initially struggles to process the news. She assures the doctor that he has nothing to be sorry for. She hangs up, finishes polishing the silver, and puts it away. Then she sits down, tries not to cry, and fails spectacularly. We pan away to their beautiful wedding photo, knowing it was all a lie, and that's exactly why this is so devastating. The quiet desperation, the crumbling facade of normalcy, and an actress finally given a chance to show us what she's capable of. Bree is the best.
This episode was good, but I am tired of this show. It just doesn't grab me. Sunday nights are crowded and they'll be getting more crowded as time goes on. And I know that the show struggled creatively after this. If I ever come back, it will be for Bree.
What Else Was On
- 30 million people watched the Desperate Housewives finale. Just let that sink in.
- Remember Jessica Lynch? Maybe you don't. She was a soldier in Iraq; she enlisted before 9/11 so she could afford a college education. She and her unit were captured, and when they returned the Bush administration and the conservative media lauded her grand heroics. Except Lynch was knocked unconscious almost immediately after her unit was ambushed, she never had the opportunity to be heroic. In exaggerating the white and blonde Lynch's heroics, the media ignored the very real heroics of her Black and Brown colleagues. Lynch was very critical of the coverage once she recovered from her injuries. She clearly felt some survivor's guilt as well, especially when it came to her Native Hopi comrade Lori Piestewa, who was severely wounded while protecting Lynch and the rest of her unit and ultimately died while in Iraqi custody. So Lynch made sure Piestwa's family and the Navajo community where they lived got the Extreme Makeover: Home Edition treatment. As always, reading these stories makes me sad and angry. Not only that people like Piestewa died for no good reason, but that all America offered them in return was a shoddy home renovation.
- 20th Century Fox had just released Revenge of the Sith into theaters, so naturally Fox aired Attack of the Clones. Apparently someone thought this was a good time to try their hand at reforming potheads with this insane anti-marijuana PSA.
- One Dateline NBC: this 911 dispatcher murdered her boyfriend!
- The final season of Queer as Folk premiered on Showtime.
- I am gagged by this super horny ad for Overstock.com. "It's all about the O." Crazy way to advertise a website that sells discount home goods.
Music, circa 2005
Meredith Grey should have been blasting this banger from Robyn's 2005 self-titled album 24/7 after the shit that McDreamy pulled. There really should have been some Robyn needle drops in Grey's Anatomy's peak era, we were robbed. A rare L from the great music supervisor Alexandra Patsavas.
TiVo Status
2 episodes of Mystery! 2 hours.