What was on TV? Thurs, May 19, 2005

The OC says "mmm whatcha say" and ER says Goodbye Carter. Plus Survivor and the Fox upfront

Share
What was on TV? Thurs, May 19, 2005

At 8 pm on May 19, 2005, most of us had never heard the words "mmmmm whatcha say." But all that was about to change. Let's see what was on TV.

8:00 The OC on Fox

2x24 "The Dearly Beloved"

The OC was all about the needle drops. Death Cab, Phantom Planet, Paint the Silence, Dice, Coldplay, Tangerine Dream, they did it all. But this is the big one.

First, it reinvigorated the show. The OC's second season had left critics and fans dissatisfied. But everyone had to admit that the final scene where Marissa shoots Trey and Ryan, Seth, and Summer can only react was teen drama at its finest. But in another world, the scene is ridiculous, desperate, silly. Instead, it's transcendent. Marissa pulls the trigger, and we hear the now-iconic chorus of Imogen Heap's "Hide and Seek." It pumps up the drama, it pumps up the tragedy, and most importantly it pumps up the ambiguity, the ambivalence. "Mmm whatcha say" indeed. What did she do? What will it mean? People would spend the whole summer wondering. A great cliffhanger, carried almost entirely by a perfect needle drop.

But this moment is way bigger than The OC. It changed Imogen Heap's life. In 2005, she had $10,000 of credit card debt. She was mostly known as the singer of Frou Frou, an electronic duo she formed with Guy Sigsworth. She remortgaged her flat and self-financed her album, writing and producing it entirely on her own to prove she wasn't just a girl singing a guy's tunes. The lead single, "Hide and Seek" was released the very same day it appeared on The OC finale. It entered the iTunes top 40 chart and closed the next volume of the OC's mega-popular series of soundtrack albums. In 2009, Hide and Seek was sampled on Jason DeRulo #1 hit "Whatcha Say." The original song is now certified Gold. Heap is one of the most respected musicians of her generation. Her fans include Taylor Swift, Ariana Grande, and the people behind KPop Demon Hunters. And I don't think she's remortgaged any flats recently.

But wait! There's more! OC superfans The Lonely Island were obsessed with this scene, and the comedic trio was about to debut on SNL. Their parody of parody of this scene made it to air in 2007. Comedy and internet culture would never be the same. But that is a story for another time.

9:00 Survivor: Palau (recorded)

10x15 "The Reunion"

The Survivor reunion was a nothingburger, as these things often are. So instead, here is my Survivor cast made entirely of characters from TV shows that also aired during the run of Palau. 12 men and 12 women, just like on that season.

  • Abby Lockhart, an ER doctor from Chicago
  • Bree van de Kamp, a housewife from Wisteria Lane
  • Bright Abbott, an office assistant from Everwood, CO
  • Debra Barone, a housewife from Long Island
  • Dina Araz, a homemaker from Los Angeles
  • Gaius Baltar, a scientist from Caprica
  • Gob Bluth, a magician from Newport Beach
  • Iroh, a military general from the Fire Nation
  • Jack Bristow, a management consultant from Los Angeles
  • Joey Tribiani, an actor from Los Angeles
  • Keith Mars, a private investigator from Neptune, CA
  • Kirsten Cohen, a magazine publisher from Newport Beach
  • Lois, a supermarket cashier from an unknown suburban town
  • Luann Platter, a hairstylist from Arlen, TX
  • Lynn Searcy, a photographer from Los Angeles
  • Rita Sue Dreifuss, a traveling dancer
  • Sayid Jarrah, a telecommunications engineer currently based in the South Pacific
  • Shane Vendrell, a cop from Los Angeles
  • Stringer Bell, a real estate developer from Baltimore
  • Trixie Star, a bartender from Deadwood, SD

A great cast, I must say. We've got pawns, players, and agents of chaos. Underdogs and people likely to play hard, aim high, and flame out. People who can slay in a talking head and people who can crush it in tribal council or transform the whole game with one conversation in the jungle. Bring it on!

Also, it was so fun giving all these people CBS-approved job titles.

10:00 ER on NBC

11x22 "The Show Must Go On"

Goodbye, John Carter of County General. Tonight ER's last remaining original character leaves the show. The character was moving to Africa, while actor Noah Wyle was moving to TNT to do more Librarians movies.

ER would continue. We'll get plenty of melodramatic disasters like tonight's building collapse in the years to come. The show will go on. But what I'll miss is the real highlight of tonight's episode, wherein Dr. Carter treats a young girl played by Keke Palmer. She is very curious, and peppers him with questions about medical terminology, procedures, and whatever she can think of. Carter has an hour of his shift left, and his patience is wearing thin. But she gets the care she needs. When her parents finally arrive, he learns that this 11-year-old is the baby girl he delivered on his first day at County General. Her parents are of course overjoyed by this coincidence, and Keke Palmer thinks it's neat too. But they don't know its significance to Carter or to us. They don't know it was his first day, and our first episode of ER. But we do. The writers and Wyle choose to underplay the moment. We don't need histrionics or grand speeches; all we need is our shared history and a doctor doing his job. And scenes like this one are what we'll lose with Carter gone. I'll miss them.

What Else Was On

  • Quentin Tarantino directed tonight's CSI, in which someone gets buried alive. But since this is Tarantino, he also had to squeeze in cameos from Tony Curtis, the recently deceased Frank Gorsuch, and a whole bunch of character actors. Normally you look at the IMDB pages of CBS guest stars and their known for is filled with other CBS shows. You check these IMDB pages and see stuff like The Miracle Worker, Enter the Dragon, Broadcast News, and Black Christmas.
  • After the previous season's three-hour finale was met with scorn and soft ratings, Trump and NBC made a big deal out of their restrained one-hour finale. He bragged about it on Conan like it was a heroic act. Of course, the finale was still three hours, it was just spread across three nights.
  • For the first time, both Apprentice finalists were women. In previous seasons, male finalists got to choose a construction job to supervise. Meanwhile, the female finalists got to choose whether they wanted to run PR for the Miss Universe pageant or supervise the renovation of a Palm Beach mansion.
  • American Idol aired a special episode composed entirely of "The World's Worst Auditions."
  • On the season finale of Will and Grace: Alec Baldwin, Eric Stoltz, AND Seth Green.

Late Night

On tonight's Conan, Amy Poehler tells us about her parents' role in the campaign to save the recently renewed Arrested Development. Poehler was married to Arrested star Will Arnett at the time, so Ma and Pa Poehler went all out. They both signed the petition and made all their friends sign it too. And this was 2005! Getting your a bunch of seniors to sign a petition wasn't as simple as sending a mass e-mail or posting to Facebook. It required real effort and hand-holding.

Meanwhile, Conan recalls how in the show's early days, when its fate remained uncertain, his mom would walk around with official Conan keychains and hand them to poor unsuspecting grocery store baggers.

Poehler and O'Brien's impression of their overly supportive parents are absolutely delightful; you must watch.

At the Fox upfront...

ABC, NBC, and CBS always gave their presentations in grand venues: Lincoln Center, Radio City Music Hall, and Carnegie Hall. Even UPN and the WB had started giving their presentations at Madison Square Garden. Fox's venue – the New York City Centre Theater – just didn't have the same air of prestige. But maybe they liked it that way. Fox loved to play the upstart.

And this year they had plenty to celebrate, grand venue or no. They started the year at number four, but they had a secret weapon: American Idol, the number one show on television. Idol returned in the new year, and Fox won February sweeps, they won May sweeps, and they won the whole year. They were number one where it mattered: in viewers ages 18-49. And it wasn't just Idol, they had other successes too. House had become a breakout hit; they successfully revived the flagging 24, holding it for midseason and running it straight through without repeats. They brought Family Guy back from the dead, and now they had another hit comedy on their schedule.

And they renewed the ratings-challenged Arrested Development. This of course earned them immense goodwill with critics. But it also highlighted something important: Fox was the premier network for comedy in this era. And this was important. The broadcast networks had struggled to develop critically and commercially successful sitcoms in recent years. Every fall saw fewer comedies on the schedule. The industry and the press had been in a state of low-level panic about this for years. What if sitcoms went extinct? Writing this blog, I certainly feel their absence. I want to laugh! I want to watch something short before bed! All these dramas, it's exhausting.

But Fox didn't just renew Arrested, it brought back nine other comedies, and picked up two new ones. Search any news database for articles about this week of upfronts and you will find dozens of articles about how many comedies are on the schedule next fall, whether the sitcom is dead, and why networks can't develop a hit sitcom to save their lives. But you will also find a lot of articles praising Fox for their commitment to comedy. They clearly pushed a narrative, and it worked.

Despite their other successes, Fox was still being carried by Idol. And superstar judge Simon Cowell seemed eager to leave, who knew if the show could survive that? So Fox bet that it would be the one to revive the sitcom. Someone had to do it, time would tell if it would be Fox.

Music, circa 2005

In case I haven't made it clear: "Hide and Seek" is really that good. And it sounds nothing like anything else in 2005. But you it also sounds exactly like 2005: the hip-hop influence, the electronic production, the dramatic sweep. But still, no one was doing it like Imogen Heap. A masterpiece.

TiVo Status

One episode of Mystery! 1 hour.