What was on TV? Wed, May 25, 2005
The hatch is open! Now you have to wait all summer to see what's inside. Plus Alias.
On May 25, 2005, we opened the hatch.

8:00 Lost on ABC
1x24-5 "Exodus Parts 2 & 3"
There's nothing like a Lost finale, and we got six of them. Exodus establishes the template: atypical flashback structure, characters split up and running around at all corners of the island, some humor, stopping the action to have a Big Philosophical Discussion, some mythology teases. And we end with an emotional montage to Michael Giacchino music and a truly sadistic cliffhanger. It's easier to love that ending when you know what comes next. But thanks to the weird rules I've imposed on myself for this project, I'll have to wait months to see what comes next (again). And I'm thrilled. I was grinning and pumping my fists on my couch at 10 pm like it was 2005 all over again.
But even with the cliffhanger and the taking of "Waaaaaaallllltttt" and the smoke monster reveal, I always come back to Artz. It should be cheap. He's such an obvious redshirt, from the very moment he was introduced two episodes ago. But his death is just so good. The smash cut from the tense dynamite removal in the ship to him ranting at Hurley outside. The fact that Hurley hates him. If Hurley can't like you, how are we supposed to like you. The writers put all the most pedantic complaints about the show in the mouth of this drip (why is the show only about the hot people? what about the other survivors?). It's so petty, I love it. And then he fat-shames Hurley, pretty much signing his death warrant. He gets to be his annoying self one last time, lecturing our esasperated series regulars about the history of nitroglycerine. Then BOOM goes the dynamite, to quote an iconic meme from the era. And boy does it ever go boom. His flesh rains down on all our series regulars and we cut to commercial. It's so gonzo, so nasty, so fun. It makes the rest of the episode way more tense, and even funny ("You've got some...Arzt...on you" lives in my head rent-free). This is how you start your finale when you're on top of the world. I'm sure lots of rubberneckers tuned into the Lost finale. How could they tune out after that?

10:00 Alias on ABC
4x22 "Before the Flood"
You know, for a minute there I thought this would make a good series finale. Sydney reconciles with her mother, Sloane redeems himself once again. She and Vaughan get their happily ever after. We needed more Dixon (as per usual) but I would have been happy with this ending. And the show's future was in doubt back in 2005. Jennifer Garner had tons of movie offers, even after Elektra flopped. The show was nearing syndication. Its ratings improved with Lost as its lead-in, but few expected it to maintain that in a tougher time slot. The show was nearing syndication, ABC would be able to recoup their investment. And tabloids were abuzz: Jennifer Garner was pregnant with Ben Affleck's baby! Maybe she wouldn't want to do those crazy Sydney Bristow stunts next year. Perhaps this could be the end.
Then Vaughan tells Sydney that his whole life and their whole relationship is a lie and they get hit by a car. So I guess we're back for another season. And we're trying to make Vaughan interesting again. We already tried that this year, and it didn't work! Just let him be the hot and supportive boyfriend that Sydney deserves.
What Else Was On
- This was the last night of the network televison season. On Thursday, May sweeps were over and it was back to reruns until September.
- And we got a juicy ratings showdown. Lost vs. American Idol. The reality monster vs. the ambitious serialized drama. Who won? Everybody! (Except Bo Bice, who lost the Idol crown to Carrie Underwood). Over 30 million people watched Idol, over 20 million people watched Lost.
- CBS was originally going to air the Martha Stewart TV movie Martha Behind Bars. But they deemed the movie too buzzy to sacrifice against the Idol vs. Lost showdown. They held it for fall, timed with the premieres Stewart's edition of The Apprentice and her daytime talk show.
- Instead, CBS aired Amber Frey: Witness for the Prosecution, starring Janel Maloney as Scott Peterson's unwitting mistress who later testified against him.
- On the final night of sweeps you pull out all the stops! Unless you're UPN. Then apparently you air the 2001 flop Swordfish for reasons I cannot fathom.
- Brad Rutter won Jeopardy's Ultimate Tournament of Champions, defeating Ken Jennings, who was hot off his record-breaking winning streak. I have distinct memories of Jennings' final Jeopardy answer, where he wrote "Go Brad!" after his guess. Rutter had so thouroughy dominated the game that his victory was all but assured.
- Two days after the Oprah Incident, Tom Cruise went after Brooke Shields in an Access Hollywood interview, criticizing her use of antidepressants.
- This is a long story, but it ends with Republican House Majority Leader Tom DeLay looking really stupid, so stay with me. In March 2005, DeLay said that the judge who ordered that the brain-dead Terri Schiavo be unplugged would "answer for [his] behavior" in time. People accused him of stoking violence against judges, especially since multiple judges had been murdered in recent months. Around this time, the writers' room for Law and Order: Criminal Intent was planning their season finale. Naturally, they looked to the headlines. So when a white supremacist murders a judge, the female lead suggests putting out an APB for someone with a Tom DeLay T-shirt. And wouldn't you know, violence against judges was back in the news when the episode aired in May. Democrats were trying to block some of Bush's more extremist judicial nominees, and comments from DeLay and Senator John Cornyn that seemed to condone violence against liberal judges who did things like legalize Gay marriage were back in the news. So great timing for Law and Order, bad timing for Delay. He was pissed and wrote network president Jeff Zucker an angry letter and then leaked it to a trade magazine. NBC responded, "This episode is in keeping with the spirit and standards of the Law & Order brand." Rare NBC win.
Late Night
Conan does a whole Star Wars segment, and it includes a Tom Cruise on Oprah bit, but not the Tom Cruise on Oprah meets Star Wars bit. The bit was inevitable in any era. The internet just made it last forever.
Music, circa 2005
A highlight of the Lost finale is Hurley's epic journey to catch the plane. A tremendous showcase for a fan-favorite character, with actor Jorge Garcia's charisma on full display. Bribing the guy on the scooter! His smile when he makes it! Hugging the gat attendant! Even summarizing it makes me smile. As usual, Giacchino's score takes the scene to a new level. This little ditty is delightful.
TiVo Status
2 episodes of Mystery! and the TV movie Trump Unauthorized. 4 hours.