What was on TV? Mon, May 16, 2005

Raymond ends, 24 vindicates me, Everwood makes me cry, plus Girlfriends and the NBC upfront.

Share
What was on TV? Mon, May 16, 2005

In May 2005, the gay cowboy movie had finally emerged from development hell. Ang Lee had finished post-production and Focus Features was preparing the release and awards campaign for Brokeback Mountain.

9:00 Everybody Loves Raymond on CBS

9x16 "The Finale" (record 24 on Fox, Girlfriends on UPN, and Everwood on the WB)

I'm used to big grandiose finales that say goodbye to everyone in exhaustive and sentimental detail. But I prefer the Raymond approach. It's definitely sentimental, and it makes for a great goodbye, but it's also just a regular episode of the show. It's understated. It leaves space for your emotions.

Ray has a minor surgery, and a nurse tells the Barones (notable sans Marie) that they can't wake him up from anesthesia. But about 30 seconds later the doctor announces he's fine. They agree to keep the whole episode secret from Ray and especially Marie, but of course it all comes out. Frank spills the beans, and Marie comes charging across the street and, in a classic bit of Raymond Freudianism, charges into his bed and embraces him right as it's getting hot and heavy with Debra. Seriously, Lucille and Buster have nothing on Ray and Marie. Eventually Robert and Amy arrive. The brush with death causes everyone to affirm their love for each other, but of course they can't just say it. They tell embarrassing stories, give awkward hugs, and engage in sign language so bizarre it verges on interpretive dance.

The next morning they all sit down to breakfast at Ray and Debra's, and soon a stove mishap sends Marie, Frank, Robert, and Amy running across the street. They eat and banter and chatter, all a little more secure in their love for one another, unspoken as it is. The camera pans away, and we see the whole family in a wide shot. Flawed but loving and lovable. It fades to black, and we say goodbye. The perfect ending.

10:00 24 (recorded)

4x22 "Day 4: 4:00 - 5:00 AM"

15 episodes ago, I wrote:

I would like to go on the record with my prediction that poor Logan Marshall-Green is gay, and that's why he's being so secretive even under horrific torture. He won't give up his boyfriend!

Called it! The poor guy doesn't have a boyfriend; it was just a one-night stand. But still, called it. Not that it was hard. Just look at that haircut.

The way 24 plays this is really gross. Of course the hawkish secratary of defense doesn't care that his son is gay. He's only disappointed that he didn't spill all his secrets to the NSA like a Real American. Hey dude, maybe it's your responsibility to make sure your son knows you'll still love him if he tells the truth! Instead, you told your daughter's boyfriend to torture him. Can't imagine why he wouldn't want to tell you this scary secret! It's all so ugly: we demand complete loyalty or else you're persona non grata. But also don't you dare call us homophobic. We're cool with you being gay. Honest.

When I made my initial prediction, I imagined a different kind of spy thriller show:

Imagine, you go to college and rebel against your dad at some protests, meet another cute boy, and discover some things about yourself. Then your Dad is kidnapped. Then shit gets super real, you are TORTURED, your dad AUTHORIZES it, and you have to decide where your loyalties lie! You betray your dirtbag Dad, go on the run, get radicalized, and hopefully get laid a few times.

I'll repeat what I said back then: someone write this book or make this show. Please.

After: Everwood (recorded)

2x21 "Oh, the Places You'll Go"

I usually watch Everwood on the train, and this is a mistake because the show regularly makes me cry. In this episode alone, we had Amy doing graduation at home because her mom can't go, while Dr. Brown celebrates Ephram's graduation alone because his son is on a plane to Europe. Meanwhile, Ephram is reading a note from his mom (Brenda Strong, our mid-2000s dead wife voiceover queen) while flying away to Europe. And before that we had Ephram and Delia's devastating goodbye, where he makes her promise to take care of their Dad because he still loves him so much. And it's too much! It's too much for me and the other people on BART.

We get all that, plus a terrific sub-plot in which Nina owns her ambitions to run the cafe as she and Jake make a bunch of mature decisions and deepen their relationship. It's classic Everwood. It's hard to make goodness and kindness and maturity compelling, but this show makes it look easy.

Later: Girlfriends (recorded)

5x21 "Wedding on the Rocks"

Very much a setup episode. Lynn's band and love life are in turmoil! Maya's ex wants to call off his wedding to his annoying fiancée and be with her! Toni is going to have that baby eventually! Tune into the season finale next week.

My favorite storyline was the one that felt like it actually resolved something. Joan and William continue to struggle with the fallout of their failed romance even as they remain committed to being friends. Here it all comes to a head in Joan's tapas bar as William drunkenly complains about its absurd design. And someone needed to say it, because this place is indeed kind of ridiculous. As William points out, there is a water feature right by the exit, right where all the drunk and tipsy people will be walking! They fight but then they laugh and they finally feel like true friends again.

This storyline has been such a joy. It takes courage to split up your OTP! But Girlfriends did it because it was the right choice. And their struggle to redefine their friendship felt authentic and unique. It was full of fits and starts but we saw their love for each other throughout; it was truly heartwarming. Plus it was hilarious. A highlight of an excellent season.

What Else Was On

  • On the season finale of The Bachelor, Jerry O'Connell's brother Charlie chose Sarah Brice but declined to propose. They dated for a few years, broke up, and then broke up for good in 2010. Five years is a lot for this show, break or no break.
  • No one can deliver a backhanded compliment like Virginia Heffernan. See her review of tonight's Hercules miniseries event on NBC: "New Zealand turns in a decent performance as ancient Greece, and – with classical buildings interpolated into the landscape – it's almost convincing, though there are maybe too many sheep and too much grass....These labors, it's a shame to say, quickly become boring, though each one gives the movie's effects crew its greatest opportunity for self-expression. The human-beast creatures are truly remarkable, and there are some scary-looking stunts, including a sudden fall from a cliff, that stand out."
  • Stephen Tobolowsky and W. Earl Brown guest-starred on tonight's CSI: Miami. Someone in that casting department loved Deadwood.
  • A truly wild collection of Special Sweeps Guest Stars tonight: Tichnia Arnold on One on One, Verne Troyer on Half and Half, Omarion on Cuts, and Eric Roberts on CSI: Miami.

TiVo Status

One episode of Desperate Housewives, one episode of Mystery!, and the Survivor reunion. 3 hours.

At the NBC Upfront...

Advertisers were seated in Radio City Music Hall. Tina Fey and Amy Poehler warmed up the crowd. They had some choice words for the competition (Amy: Two and a Half Men – that's how many people it would take to hold me down to watch it"). But the best and meanest jokes were reserved for their employer. Tina: "Buy NBC. Because out of over a hundred TV channels, we're number four. And that's pretty good." Amy twisted the knife: "We'd like to promise you that next year things will be better. But we can't." More barbs followed. "In TV news, the NBC executives who last year picked LAX, Hawaii and Father of the Pride have completed rehab." "NBC is broadcasting more and more of its programs in high-def. The picture is so clear that last week on Joey, you could actually see Matt LeBlanc's panic."

NBC had an abysmal year, going from first to fourth. NBC traditionally dominated upfronts, where networks present their new shows to advertisers who buy airtime for the following year. NBC always sold the most, thanks to their big ratings and popularity with the viewers that advertisers covet: adults between the ages of 18-49 and rich people. They were number one in ad sales the previous year, even with Friends no longer on the schedule: they showed them the full pilot of spin-off Joey and advertisers signed the checks. This was their domain. NBC was now number four, but they were still number one among rich people and they were confident they could sell lots of ads based on that. Analysts expected a loss of half a billion versus last year, but surely it wouldn't be that bad.

Entertainment president Kevin Reilly starred in a taped parody of Apocalypse Now chronicling his nightmarish first year on the job and featuring Martin Sheen himself. But one insider who quoted in Bill Carter's Desperate Networks reflected the general sentiment: this was Jeff Zucker's fault. Contemporary articles echo this sentiment. Zucker kept NBC at number one through smoke and mirrors and gimmicks for several years while failing to develop a single hit show. Kevin Reilly was just one man who failed to do so under his leadership. Now the whole network was paying for his bad decisions.

The presentation proved underwhelming. The Jerry Bruckheimer-produced military drama E-Ring was dismissed as boring. Martha Stewart, fresh from prison, was headlining a new version of The Apprentice (it was initially thought that she would replace Trump, but he refused to step down). Yet she was treated almost like an afterthought, strange when NBC was investing so much in her (she was also premiering a syndicated daytime talk show on several of their affiliates).

The sole bright spot was new comedy My Name is Earl got a few laughs and got critics. The sitcom was practically an endangered species in 2005, so any comedy that showed a whiff of promise got hyped to the moon by advertisers and critics. But Earl was about a redneck who wins the lottery. Such a blue-collar and rural show seemed like a strange fit for a network that built its brand around courting rich young city-dwellers, and who spend the past hour bragging about its success with households spending $100,000 a year or moe. Furthermore, NBC had struggled to find anything to pair Earl with: they were running out of comedies. Kevin Reilly and producer/nepo baby/eventual Kevin Reilly replacement Ben Silverman finally convinced Zucker to pair it with the second season of The Office. Kevin Reilly loved the show (that Apocalypse Now parody was filmed on the Office set). But Zucker was determined to cancel it (the underperformance of Scrubs had convinced him that all single-camera comedies were doomed). He finally agreed to bring it back for six episodes at a reduced license fee.

Also on the schedule: obligatory Lost copycat Threshold (later retitled Surface). Every network also had a feel-good reality show, trying to capture the success of ABC's Extreme Makeover: Home Edition. NBC's attempt was Three Wishes, hosted by Amy Grant. Inconceivable, a drama set at a fertility clinic. And Joey, whose second season renewal was met with snickers and eye-rolls. Advertisers were unimpressed.

All told, NBC lost over a billion in ad sales versus the previous year. It was official: the peacock's season from hell was complete. But their flop era was far from over. One year later, Tina Fey would be back at Upfronts, this time with her new comedy 30 Rock. That show would spend the next seven years turning NBC's woes into comedy gold.

As you can perhaps tell from this write-up, I love NBC's flop era. The shows were great, and they survived and thrived in an era of astonishing corporate incompetence. Sometimes they survived despite that incompetence; sometimes they scraped by precisely because NBC was so incompetent. Great TV and schadenfreude? I couldn't ask for anything more. I'll be here to chronicle every great episode and Jeff Zucker faceplant, however long it takes.