What was on TV? Tues, May 17 2005

House levels up. Plus the Sheild, Desperate Housewives, Britney Spears, and the CBS upfront

Share
What was on TV? Tues, May 17 2005

In May 2005, Britney Spears was pregnant and putting her home videos on UPN, of all places. Let's see what was on TV.

8:00 Desperate Housewives (recorded)

1x22 "Goodbye for Now"

Everyone was wondering how Desperate Housewives would follow up the Mary Alice mystery. I hate this mystery plot, but the way it began? Oh my. That moment when Mary Alice goes through her routine in her suburban fantasy life is exquisite. How do you top that?

Here, we see Desperate Housewives plan: you hire Alfre Woodard! This is not a bad idea. Desperate Housewives had earned a reputation as something of a career rehab center for actresses of a certain age, and Woodard is one of the finest actors in the world. Who would't want to see her dig into some juicy material like Marcia Cross or Felicity Huffman?

Unfortunately, the Alfre Woodard storyline would prove a disappointment. The mystery, her character, and the entire season were poorly received. And like many shows of the mid-2000s, Desperate Housewives would stumble and sputter when it tried to diversity its cast and explore race.

9:00 House on Fox

1x21 "Three Stories"

"Three Stories" is preceded by its reputation. It is critically adored, even by people who are neutral on House. David Shore won an Emmy for his script. He beat "Walkabout" from Lost and the season three finale of The Wire. But I haven't loved a single episode from House's first season. Could Three Stories live up to the hype.

I am delighted to say that it did. It's no surprise that it won the Emmy. It's very clever, it plays with structure, it has a cool twist. House has to give a lecture, so he tells three stories about patients who presented with leg pain. We hip and hop between the three patients and the lecture and back again. Carmen Elektra is there, in an egregious piece of stunt casting, but the stunt casting actually deepens the episode instead of cheapening it, somehow. A real magic trick. It's definitely the most writing in the category, of course it won. But it's also so good! The overly clever structure suits House, whose title character is too clever by half.

This isn't just a showy piece of Emmy bait. It works brilliantly as a standalone; that's why it won. But more than that, it makes the whole show better. The lecture format shows us how House thinks it allows us to play along. The students make for great audience surrogates. Sometimes it feels like House doesn't want you to find the answer, only to bask in the leading man's genius, and I find that a little boring. Here, it feels like he's teaching us. Because twist: House turns out to be a pretty good teacher! It's a surprising development that deepens his character.

But of course the main thing is that twist. Because surprise! One of the patients is House (he initially cast himself as Carmen Elektra). And seeing House as a patient makes him so much more interesting. No longer is he the imperious grump, always right. Now he's just a patient: he makes bad decisions. He's weak. He's self-destructive. Seeing that makes the rest of the show twice as interesting.

10:00 The Shield on FX

4x09 "String Theory"

The Shield doesn't get enough credit for its visual style. Shaky-cam was huge in the mid-2000s thanks to the Bourne movies, but The Shield did it first. The show also doesn't get enough credit for its sound design. As chaos descends, we hear flies buzzing, the radio playing at the liquor store, zip ties rattling, glass breaking. We hear it all, and it's never subtle. It's intimate and aggressive. That's Farmington, that's the world Vic believes in and creates. Danger is always there, and everyone is always up in each other's space. The cops, criminals, criminal cops, and citizens can't stay out of each other's business; everyone is always crossing lines that shouldn't be crossed and making each other miserable.

At the end of the episode, the season's big bad Antwone (Anthony Anderson) is brought in. Vic and and Captain Rawlins (Glenn Close) enter. Vic uncuffs Antwone, jingle. They close the door, clang. Rawlins says thanks for coming in. Silence. We pan to him. We pan to Vic, lurking in the corner. His eyes shift to Rawlins. Cut to black. Perfection. If you're going to use sound, you have to use silence too.

What Else Was On

  • Britney and Kevin: Chaotic, a reality show that promised to chronicle Britney Spears' marriage to Kevin Federline in the vein of Newlyweds: Nick and Jessica, premiered on UPN. But I wouldn't call this a reality show. It's just a bunch of Britney's home videos, cobbled together. It feels more like a vlog. Britney was always ahead of her time. I watched a few minutes and it's compelling, Spears is magnetic as always. But I felt gross, like a voyeur. I think a lot of people felt the same. You'd expect this to air on MTV or Vh1, but it ended up on UPN. It received minimal coverage. Even at the height of Britney-mania, there just wasn't an appetite for something like this.
  • On the season finale of Gilmore Girls: Rory quits Yale! Mother and daughter basically break up! Luke proposes!
  • On the season finale of According to Jim: should Kimberly Williams-Paisley get married?
  • On the season finale of the soon-to-be-cancelled My Wife and Kids: Tisha Campbell wants her husband Damon Wayans to get a vasectomy.
  • Special sweeps guest stars: NFL quarterbacks Duante Culpepper and Donovan McNabb on George Lopez, Marlee Matlin on Law and Order: SVU, John Travolta's niece on One Tree Hill
  • At the 40th annual Academy of Country Music Awards, they hyped up Toby Keith's appearance via satellite from an "undisclosed location in Iraq." They cut to him, and he goes "Welcome to Honkytonk University y'all, we're in Baghdad." Whoops!
  • Sugarland closed the show with a performance of their first single "Baby Girl." Great song.

Late Night

NBC made Conan interview Trump. Conan still hates him. He is still so pissed about that Trump building that "bricked over his window." On Trump's ignorance when it comes to international versions of The Apprentice: "as long as they pay, you don't care." Trump sucks up to the boss: "NBC's gonna be just fine, Jeff Zucker's done an amazing job." Conan's "...sure" is absolutely perfect. Conan likes everyone, including some proper assholes. But he really hated Trump, my god.

TiVo Status

One episode of Mystery! and the Survivor reunion. 2 hours.

At the CBS Upfront...

CBS president Les Moonves should have been triumphant in Carnegie Hall. His network was about to complete a stellar season. Their signature hits CSI and Survivor were as strong as ever. Everybody Loves Raymond had concluded with a well-received final season. Now the highest-rated comedy on TV was Two and a Half Men, another CBS show. The risky decision to move Without a Trace to Thursdays at 10 pm opposite ER had paid off; Without a Trace had already beaten ER several times that season. They'd successfully launched a third CSI spinoff with CSI: NY, while JAG spinoff NCIS had grown in its second season. They turned a show about using math to solve murders with the ridiculous title Numb3rs into a bona fide hit. The Amazing Race had grown from a critical darling on the brink of cancellation into a ratings powerhouse. Fox was going to win the season in the prized 18-49 demographic, but that was mostly thanks to the Super Bowl and a blockbuster baseball postseason. CBS had several smash hits. It had stability. It was built to last. It was a winner, and everyone knew it.

Moonves was a winner too. In a taped segment featuring CBS reality stars, Moonves' new wife Julie Chen (host of CBS' Big Brother and The Early Show proudly brandished an "immunity ring," foreshadowing "immunity idols," which would be introduced in the next season of Survivor. But it was also a blatant display of power. Moonves started dating Chen while she was his employee, and while he was still married to his first wife. Were he someone else, people would question this behavior. But no one questioned Les Moonves. He was one of the most powerful people in Hollywood. All the other network presidents were one bad season away from losing their jobs. Not Moonves. He had the respect of the industry and the media, a clear path up the company ladder, and a beautiful new wife. He had it all.

So why was he so bitter? The show opened with the cast of Avenue Q singing "It Sucks to Be Me," replacing their regular Broadway puppets with ones that resembled Bob Iger, Jeff Zucker, and Rupert Murdoch. Meanwhile, a puppet resembling Moonves sang "It's Great to Be Me." (To quote Bill Carter in his book Desperate Networks, "Why Murdoch and Iger would have been so depressed at the end of their patently successful television seasons was not addressed.") He seemed peevish about Fox's win, stressing that it came on a technicality. He even took out a full-page ad in the New York Times, declaring that CBS was number one in all categories (a tiny asterisk at the bottom clarified this was "among scheduled programming."

Every network wants to court young male viewers. This is America, after all. But Moonves seemed fixated on it. A pop psychologist would've had a field day with this presentation. CBS was the Murder She Wrote network when Moonves started working there, the place to be for women of a certain age. CBS had mostly shed this reputation but Moonves was still defensive about it. Suburban legal drama will skew "more male than Judging Amy did." Plus it would have "more male appeal" thanks to a younger and hotter lead. His number two Nina Tassler was more subtle, describing the twentysomething hangout sitcom How I Met Your Mother as "an important step in the right demographic direction." Moonves explained that their Sunday TV Movie franchise would try offiering counterprogramming to Desperate Housewives, shifting away from female-driven stories to "B-movies about locusts and sharks." No, the Wednesday edition of 60 Minutes wasn't axed because of the forged documents scandal, its audience was just too old. Same with JAG and Joan of Arcadia. The latter show was replaced with the Jennifer Love Hewitt vehicle Ghost Whisperer. One reporter asked "Why is it that you think a show with a 25-year-old who talks to ghosts is going to do well in the same time period where you had an 18-year-old talking to God?" Moonves fired back, "I think talking to ghosts may skew younger than talking to God."

But Moonves' resentment of NBC president Jeff Zucker took the cake. Everyone was taking shots at NBC this week, that's what happens when a network goes from first to fourth. But with Moonves, it seemed nastier, more personal. It started at a pre-upfront breakfast, where Moonves was so vicious towards Zucker that trade magazine Broadcasting and Cable ran an entire story about it (they counted 11 Zucker digs in one hour). At the presentation for advertisers in Carnegie Hall, "Jeffrey Zucker was bashed constantly," according to TV Week. Moonves pointed to double-digit declines in NBC's Thursday night lineup, then pointed out they just renewed the entire night. "Must-see TV is history. Must-buy TV is CBS."

Fair enough. But he just couldn't stop. In a taped parody of Million Dollar Baby, he was faced with the titanic task of becoming the "18-49 champ" and knocked out boxers in robes reading "LAX," "Hawaii," and "Father of the Pride" – all failed NBC shows. It's so violent. At one point, the Clint Eastwood character felt he wasn't punching hard enough. Then they inserted a photo of Zucker onto the bag, and he blasted it off the screen. It feels a little too revealing; I felt embarrassed reading about it. Even the boxing premise felt like a dig. NBC's boxing reality show The Contender had been another high-profile failure for the network. And Moonves had gone out of his way to kill that show, airing reruns during sweeps so he could air new episodes of their biggest hits opposite The Contender.

I'm no Zucker defender (just read my dispatch from the NBC upfront). But this feels a little excessive. You won! This viciousness and defensiveness is just nasty. It's ugly. You might say that this insatiable thirst for his enemies' blood is what made Moonves successful. Maybe you're right. But Moonves' behavior – the vindictiveness, the pettiness, the ever-present hunger for something younger and more masculine. Throwing his extramarital relationship with an employee in everyone's faces. It all speaks to a rot at the heart of the company. In 2018, we would learn that Moonves had an extensive history of workplace harassment and assault; he was by far the most powerful person taken down by #MeToo. We would also learn that misogyny and abuse were pervasive throughout the company. In those crime dramas, in the news division, among stars and shows big and small. Some people got fired, but not that many. The Paramount and CBS that exist today, the company that just bought Warner Brothers? That company was shaped by Les Moonves.

Music, circa 2005

Even when Britney's life was chaos, she remained one of the most musically innovative and adventurous pop stars. Case in point: she released some random bonus tracks to promote her UPN reality show, and one of those tracks was produced by Robyn and Imogen Heap. You can even her Imogen singing backing vocals! "Over to You Now" is fun, though it's hardly a highlight in these women's careers.

But still! Britney was always ahead of the curve. Robyn was not yet the pop auteur we know love, she only just begun to shed her teenybopper image with the April release of her self-titled album, which barely came out in the America. Imogen Heap would blow up in just two days thanks to The OC's use of "Hide and Seek" but before that she was nobody! And yet Britney looked at this British weirdo and this Swedish one-hit-wonder and saw two of the foremost musical minds of her generation. Brava.