What was on TV? Wed, May 18 2005

Share
What was on TV? Wed, May 18 2005

In May 2005, Democrats pissed everyone off by using the filibuster to block some of Bush's more extremist judicial nominees. Where is this energy today? Let's see what was on TV.

8:00 Lost on ABC

1x23 "Exodus Part 1" (record ANTM on UPN)

Lost was a runaway hit and the public was voracious for their promised answers. Would we see what was inside the hatch? Would we see the monster? Would we see the others? ABC was going to milk that desire for all it was worth right through the end of May sweeps. So Lost finished a full 22-episode season and the network asked them to do a three-part finale on top of that. It could have gone horribly wrong. The cast, crew, and writers were all burnt out and exhausted. A three-part finale threatened to exhaust the fans too. Not too long ago, The Apprentice did a three-hour finale, and the audience revolted. Lost's finale would air across two weeks but it very easily could have felt like a craven and misshapen ratings grab.

But they nailed it. The first part of "Exodus" is a perfect prologue. We have the structure: flashbacks that track the castaways as they board Oceanic Flight 815. We have the stakes: the Others are coming. We have our objectives: find the dynamite, blow open the hatch, launch the raft, and find rescue. The set-up is all done, now the finale proper can hit the ground running next week.

But this episode never feels like set-up. How could it when it has one of the best endings in all of television? Lost is full of superb scenes, but few can top the raft launch. We roam among the castaways, watching as they all say goodbye. It builds on the relationships and characters we've come to know and love across these 23 episodes, and it does so beautifully. Michael and Sun saying a silent goodbye, Sawyer looking for Kate, Charlie collecting messages. Lost always looks beautiful, but the image of the raft in the crystal clear water, everyone cheering as the mast is raised ranks among the show's best. Michael Giacchino's score builds and builds, and I smile through my tears. And then there's the Vincent. If you weren't already moved, the bit with the dog would feel cheap. Instead, it's the cherry on top of the sundae. Giacchino's score somehow keeps building as we see Jin and Sun gaze at each other, estranged spouses and star-crossed lovers all at once. Saving the best relationship on that beach for last. I've seen it dozens of times now, and it never fails to catch me off guard. We pan out and the score thrums with one triumphant note as the raft sails away. It really doesn't get any better than this.

9:00 Alias on ABC

4x20 "The Descent" and 4x21 "Search and Rescue"

They tried killing her. They tried bringing in other titans of World cinema to play her sisters. But you cannot replace the original baddie. You cannot replace Lena Olin, and you cannot replace Irina Derevko.

Thank god she's back. The episode opens with Jack killing her (or rather her doppelganger). I was okay with Irina dying, what pissed me off was the fact that we never got to see Victor Garber and Lena Olin do one last scene together. This was all I dreamed and more. Of course, she has to be found in the most extra way imaginable: buried in a Mayan ruin but still looking insanely hot. And then we're off to the races, like she never left.

On another note, Vaughn proposes to Sydney, and it's very sweet. Him asking her dad for permission, also sweet. In between, they do an operation in a club and allude to their BDSM activities while her dad and their co-workers listen in and "My Neck, My Back (Lick It)" plays. Not so sweet! Actually kind of insane!

11:00 America's Next Top Model (recorded)

4x13 "The Girl Who Walks on Water"

The sad truth is that the people who love ANTM are in it for the drama and Tyra's crazy antics, sure. But we also like to see nice pictures! The horrors go down a lot easier when the pictures are good. In cycle 3, the final three all had gorgeous Covergirl photos. You could see each and every one in Seventeen magazine, no problem. And when we got a portfolio showdown between finalists Eva and Yaya, their pictures were all really good!

In cycle 4, we get three awkward Covergirl photos that the judges have to pretend are amazing. It's not all the girls' fault; the setup was ugly. But that doesn't change the results. And the portfolio showdown between finalists Naima and Kahlen is underwhelming. And while both girls seem nice, neither is super memorable.

When the photos don't dazzle and the personalities don't pop, all that's left is the ugliness. This season alone we had sexual assault, a blackface photoshoot, fatshaming, and more. I haven't even touched on the Tiffany of it all. So much ugliness, and so few pretty pictures to wash the taste away. Maybe that's a good thing. ANTM was fun, but it was also evil, and we should always remember that.

What Else Was On

  • On the season finale of Smallville: Jor-El (the voice of Terrence Stamp) tells Clark that he needs to reunite the three crystals and save the world! 8 minutes of exclusive footage from Batman Begins premiered on this episode.
  • Topher Grace and Ashton Kutcher both departed That 70s Show, as they were now bona-fide movie actors (Ashton was a successful TV producer as well; his reality show Beauty and the Geek would debut in two weeks).
  • In honor of the impending premiere of Revenge of the Sith, Animal Planet aired "Animal Icons: Star Wars Creatures."
  • Vonzell Solomon went home on Idol, leaving Carrie Underwood and Bo Bice as the final two. She got stuck in development hell, and was the highest-finishing Idol contestant to not get a record contract to that point. A shame, I liked what I saw of her.
  • Dateline NBC investigated Virgin Mary sightings around the world.
  • On the final episode of the soon-to-be-cancelled Taye Diggs vehicle Kevin Hill: Wayne Brady, Toni Braxton, Meagan Good, and Diggs' real-life spouse Idina Menzel all guest-starred.
  • ABC News aired a special report on judicial appointments. They explored a recent dustup in the Senate, where Domocrats were trying to filibusters some of Bush's more extremist judicical nominees. Then they interviewed several citizens in Georgia who felt that the courts were overriding public opinion with all these liberal judgments on stuff like abortion, school prayer, and especially gay marriage. A fascinating time capsule which shows us the anger that inspired conservatives to take back control of the courts.
  • 17-year-old Desperate Housewives star Cody Kasch was arrested for marijuana possession. Desperate Housewives had becomes a fixture in the tabloids, this was all over the nightly news and the New York Post. Leave the kid alone! Leave the drama to the divas of a certain age!

Late Night

Sigh. There was a stand-up set on tonight's Conan. The mid-2000s were a great era for television. It was a great era of music. It was a pretty good era for movies. There were good books, iconic fashion.

But judging by what I've seen, the mid-2000s were a terrible era for stand-up comedy. In the 90s, any dude with a decent set got a sitcom. In the past decade, the streaming era and the internet have given us a true comedy boom. But the mid-2000s? Not inspiring. Every act that got booked on late night bored me to tears, the only exception was Zach Galifianakis. When I see that a stand-up comic is booked on Conan, I groan. Who wants to listen to hacky jokes about breast implants or the Michael Jackson trial. The floppiest of flop indie bands would be more pleasant.

At the ABC upfront...

At the 2004 upfront, Jimmy Kimmel got a lot of laughs when he compared ABC to the kid who eats paste. One year later in Lincoln Center, all he could muster was a limp joke about the cancelled cop show Blind Justice ("we put on a show about a blind guy that nobody saw"). But he could only bemoan his employer's good fortune: "all this success, they've ruined it for me." He wasn't even the big moment of this presentation. The big moment was Desperate Housewives creator Marc Cherry walking out and belting out Stephen Sondheim's "Beautiful Girls," welcoming his leading ladies to the stage. Advertisers in the audience gave him a standing ovation, the only one of the entire week.

ABC's 2004-5 season was a dream. I would say it was the stuff of TV executive fantasies, but even TV executives might not to dare to imagine a season like this. You launch not just one buzzy supernova smash hit (Lost) but two (Desperate Housewives). You back that up with two more solid new shows (Wife Swap, Boston Legal). Your feel-good home makeover spinoff of your plastic surgery show is suddenly the hot new reality hit. And then, in the spring, you somehow launch a third supernova smash hit. ABC's overall ratings grew 17 percent in the 18-49 demographic that advertisers love, the highest increase for a broadcast network since Nielsen got serious about measuring this stuff. Like I said, a dream.

But dreams end. Supernova serialized hits like Lost and Desperate Housewives tend to burn bright and fast. Could either show maintain the momentum through a second season and beyond? ABC still had no strong comedies. They were now the only network without a solid hit on Thursday, television's most profitable night.

More importantly, the people who developed Lost and Desperate Housewives, the shows that changed ABC's fortunes, were all gone now. They'd been fired. New ABC president Steve McPherson was keenly aware of this fact. He and his team were eager to prove they could develop hits on their own. Many felt he couldn't do it, the kind of luck ABC experienced in 2004 doesn't come around very often. But McPherson had good reason to believe he was up to the task: he had been instrumental in developing Grey's Anatomy, the third in ABC's hat trick of new megahits. Now he just had to do it again, or he'd be facing a lot of grumpy advertisers in a year's time.

Music, circa 2005

Michael Giacchino has an Oscar and three Grammys since 2005, but "Parting Words" remains his greatest work.

TiVo Status

One episode of Mystery! and the Survivor reunion. 2 hours.